Strategy Studio · Stage 2 of 4: Generate options

BCG portfolio matrix

Plot a product portfolio by relative market share and market growth, with each product's revenue as the size of its circle, and get guidance on the balance of the portfolio.

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

m for millions, k for thousands, or blank.

Market growth at or above this counts as high.

Products

For each product, its share of its own market, the share of the largest rival in that market (the next largest, if the product leads), how fast the market grows and the product's revenue.

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

The portfolio on the matrix

BCG matrix: Northvale CyclesBCG matrix for Northvale Cycles. City and trekking bikes: relative market share 1.50, market growth −1.0%, revenue €15m, a cash cow; Commuter e-bikes: relative market share 0.33, market growth 12.0%, revenue €10.5m, a question mark; Cargo e-bikes: relative market share 1.50, market growth 22.0%, revenue €6m, a star; Children's bikes: relative market share 0.25, market growth 2.0%, revenue €4m, a dog; Road bikes: relative market share 0.21, market growth 0.0%, revenue €2.5m, a dog. The growth line is at 5.0% and the share line at a relative share of 1.STARSQUESTION MARKSCASH COWSDOGS10×5×2×1×0.5×0.2×0.1×−5%0%5%10%15%20%25%30%growth line 5.0%Relative market share (log scale, high on the left)Market growth, % a yearCity and trekking bikes €15mCommuter e-bikes €10.5mCargo e-bikes €6mChildren's bikes €4mRoad bikes €2.5m

Relative share is the product's market share divided by the largest rival's: above 1 means it leads its market. The area of each circle is proportional to revenue (very small products keep a minimum size).

Each product's shares, relative market share, market growth, revenue and place in the matrix
ProductMarket shareLargest rivalRelative shareMarket growthRevenueShare of revenueCategory
City and trekking bikes18.0%12.0%1.50−1.0%€15m39%Cash cow
Commuter e-bikes6.0%18.0%0.3312.0%€10.5m28%Question mark
Cargo e-bikes24.0%16.0%1.5022.0%€6m16%Star
Children's bikes5.0%20.0%0.252.0%€4m11%Dog
Road bikes3.0%14.0%0.210.0%€2.5m7%Dog
Portfolio€38m100%

Portfolio guidance

  • Five products: one star, one question mark, one cash cow and two dogs. By revenue, stars 16%, question marks 28%, cash cows 39% and dogs 17%.
  • City and trekking bikes is the cash cow, earning 39% of revenue. The usual advice is to hold it, spend little on growth, and use the cash to fund the stars and question marks. City and trekking bikes is in a shrinking market (−1.0% a year), so this cash will fall: the portfolio needs a successor.
  • Cargo e-bikes is a star: a leading share of a fast-growing market, which usually takes heavy investment to defend. As the market slows, a star that keeps its lead becomes the next cash cow.
  • Commuter e-bikes is a question mark, earning 28% of revenue. Decide: invest to build its share towards the lead, or withdraw before it absorbs more cash.
  • Children's bikes and Road bikes are dogs, earning 17% of revenue between them. Keep a dog only if it covers its costs or supports the rest of the range; otherwise consider dropping or selling it.
  • In outline the portfolio is balanced: cash from the cows can fund the products that may replace them. It stays balanced only while the cows keep earning and the stars keep their lead.

The guidance follows the usual reading of the matrix. It is a starting point for judgement: a dog can be worth keeping, and a star can still lose money.

Checks

No problems found: every product has complete figures.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To see a business's products side by side by the strength of their market position and the growth of their markets, so that cash can be moved from the products that generate it to the products that need it, and weak products can be questioned.

IB syllabus status

IB toolkit tool SL and HL

The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) matrix is one of the guide's toolkit tools for SL and HL, suggested for units 3 and 4 (Business management guide, p. 14), and taught at AO2 and AO4 alongside the syllabus content (p. 13). It draws on market share and market growth (4.1) and the product portfolio (4.5). The guide names the matrix without fixing its axes; this tool uses relative market share, and some textbooks use market share instead.

Serves 4.1 Introduction to marketing , 4.5 The seven Ps of the marketing mix

How to use it

  1. Add each product with its market share, the share of the largest rival in its market (the next largest, if the product leads), the growth of its market and its revenue.
  2. Set the growth line, the market growth that counts as high. There is no fixed rule; one approach is to use the average growth of the markets the business is in.
  3. Read the chart. Relative share above 1 means the product leads its market; the circles' areas show revenue.
  4. Read the portfolio guidance: what the cash cows can fund, which question marks to back, and which dogs to question.
  5. Use the result in the option appraisal: which products should the strategy invest in, hold or drop?

Limitations

  • Market share and market growth are only two measures. Profit, cash flow and how products support each other are not on the chart.
  • The labels depend on where the lines are drawn and on how the market is defined. A product can look like a dog in a broad market and a star in a niche.
  • A dog is not always worth dropping. It may cover its costs, complete a range or keep a key customer.
  • It assumes high share brings low costs and high growth needs cash. That holds in many markets, but not in all.
  • It is a snapshot. Positions change as markets grow and mature.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to turn the picture into decisions about money. Say which products fund which, and what happens when the cash cow's market keeps shrinking. For Northvale, city bikes pay for the cargo bike's growth today, but at −1% a year that cash will not last, which is why the cargo bike, the star, sits at the centre of the strategy.

Read alongside