Advanced financial analysis · Beyond the IB course
Break-even scenarios
Which cost structure earns more, at what volume does the answer change, and which carries more risk?
Back to 5.5 Break-even analysis Also for 5.6 Production planning (HL)
- Beyond the IB course
- Builds on IB 5.5, 5.6, the toolkit
- Undergraduate, MBA, professional and teacher
- Simulated data Example: Emberly Roasters, fictional
The comparison
Example figures: Emberly Roasters, a fictional business. Simulated data.
The comparison could not start. The worked example below uses the example figures.
The figures
- Selling price per bag
- $24.00
- Forecast sales per month
- 3,600 bags
- Capacity per month
- 4,500 bags
- Automate the packing: fixed costs per month
- $31,625
- Automate the packing: variable cost per bag
- $13.30
- Outsource the packing: fixed costs per month
- $25,600
- Outsource the packing: variable cost per bag
- $14.90
Changing these figures needs JavaScript. With it switched off, the page shows the full worked example for the figures above.
Your figures are kept in this browser once you change them. Nothing is sent anywhere.
Result
These results are for the last complete figures. Correct the figure marked in the inputs to update them.
Indifference volume
3,765.6 bags a month
Automate the packing earns more above it, from 3,766 bags; Outsource the packing earns more below it
- Better at the forecast Beyond the IB course
- Outsource the packingby $265 a month
- Change in sales before the other earns more Beyond the IB course
- +4.6%from the forecast of 3,600 bags
- Break-even quantity IB
- 2,956 and 2,814Automate the packing, then Outsource the packing
- Margin of safety IB
- 17.9% and 21.8%of forecast sales, in the same order
- Degree of operating leverage IB HL
- 5.59 and 4.58Automate the packing is the riskier structure
Section 01: The two structures side by side
Break-even, the margin of safety and profit, from the IB course, beside the measures that go beyond it.
| Measure | Standing | Automate the packing | Outsource the packing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed costs per month | IB | $31,625 | $25,600 |
| Variable cost per bag | IB | $13.30 | $14.90 |
| Contribution per bag | IB | $10.70 | $9.10 |
| Contribution as a share of the price | Beyond the IB course | 44.6% | 37.9% |
| Break-even quantity | IB | 2,956 bags | 2,814 bags |
| Break-even revenue | IB | $70,934.58 | $67,516.48 |
| Margin of safety | IB | 644 bags (17.9%) | 786 bags (21.8%) |
| Profit at the forecast (3,600 bags) | IB | $6,895 | $7,160 |
| Profit at capacity (4,500 bags) | IB | $16,525 | $15,350 |
| Degree of operating leverage at the forecast | IB HL | 5.59 | 4.58 |
For comparison, packing as Emberly Roasters does now, in the Financial Laboratory’s month: fixed costs of $29,000 and a variable cost of $14.40 a bag earn $5,560 at 3,600 bags, with a degree of operating leverage of 6.22. The example’s two structures earn $6,895 and $7,160 at the same volume.
Section 02: Profit at every volume
Where each structure breaks even, where they cross, and the forecast between.
The chart’s figures as a table
| Volume | Automate the packing | Outsource the packing | Difference | Earns more |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2,160 bags (−40% on the forecast) | −$8,513 | −$5,944 | $2,569 | Outsource the packing |
| 2,520 bags (−30% on the forecast) | −$4,661 | −$2,668 | $1,993 | Outsource the packing |
| 2,880 bags (−20% on the forecast) | −$809 | $608 | $1,417 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,240 bags (−10% on the forecast) | $3,043 | $3,884 | $841 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,600 bags (the forecast) (the figures as entered) | $6,895 | $7,160 | $265 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,960 bags (+10% on the forecast) | $10,747 | $10,436 | $311 | Automate the packing |
| 4,320 bags (+20% on the forecast) | $14,599 | $13,712 | $887 | Automate the packing |
| 4,500 bags (capacity) | $16,525 | $15,350 | $1,175 | Automate the packing |
| Volume | Automate the packing | Outsource the packing | Difference | Earns more |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2,160 bags (−40% on the forecast) | −$8,513 | −$5,944 | $2,569 | Outsource the packing |
| 2,520 bags (−30% on the forecast) | −$4,661 | −$2,668 | $1,993 | Outsource the packing |
| 2,880 bags (−20% on the forecast) | −$809 | $608 | $1,417 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,240 bags (−10% on the forecast) | $3,043 | $3,884 | $841 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,600 bags (the forecast) (the figures as entered) | $6,895 | $7,160 | $265 | Outsource the packing |
| 3,960 bags (+10% on the forecast) | $10,747 | $10,436 | $311 | Automate the packing |
| 4,320 bags (+20% on the forecast) | $14,599 | $13,712 | $887 | Automate the packing |
| 4,500 bags (capacity) | $16,525 | $15,350 | $1,175 | Automate the packing |
Reading. The difference between the two grows by $1.60 for every bag sold: the gap in contribution per bag. It is zero at the indifference volume, 3,765.6 bags.
Section 03: The working
Each structure’s break-even, margin of safety and operating leverage in eight parts, and the indifference volume.
Automate the packing: break-even, margin of safety and operating leverage
Break-even quantity IB
- Given
- Fixed costs per month: $31,625
- Selling price per bag: $24.00
- Variable cost per bag: $13.30
- Formula
- Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit
- Substitution
- = $31,625 ÷ ($24.00 − $13.30)
- Working
- Contribution per unit = 24.00 − 13.30 = 10.7031,625.00 ÷ 10.70 = 2,955.61
- Answer
- 2,956 bags
Rounded up, not to the nearest whole number: at 2,955 bags the result would be a loss of $6.50.
- Unit
- bags per month
- Interpretation
- Automate the packing covers every cost from 2,956 bags a month.
- Business implication
- A lower break-even leaves more room for sales to fall before a loss.
Margin of safety IB
- Given
- Forecast sales per month: 3,600 bags
- Fixed costs per month: $31,625
- Selling price per bag: $24.00
- Variable cost per bag: $13.30
- Formula
- Margin of safety = forecast (or actual) output − break-even output
- Substitution
- = 3,600 − ($31,625 ÷ ($24.00 − $13.30))
- Working
- Break-even output = 31,625.00 ÷ 10.70 = 2,955.61, rounded up to 2,9563,600 − 2,956 = 644As a share of forecast sales: 644 ÷ 3,600 × 100 = 17.9%
- Answer
- 644 bags
Sales could fall by 644 bags (17.9%) before the business makes a loss.
- Unit
- bags per month
- Interpretation
- Sales could fall by 644 bags before Automate the packing makes a loss.
- Business implication
- The margin of safety is the cushion against a forecast that proves too high.
Degree of operating leverage IB HL
- Given
- Total contribution at 3,600 bags: $38,520
- Profit at the forecast: $6,895
- Formula
- Degree of operating leverage = total contribution ÷ profit
- Substitution
- = 38,520.00 ÷ 6,895.00
- Working
- 38,520.00 ÷ 6,895.00 = 5.5867
- Answer
- 5.59
The guide names operating leverage in 5.6 (HL) but gives no formula; this is the standard one the platform’s notes use.
- Unit
- a multiple: the per cent change in profit for each 1% change in sales
- Interpretation
- A 10% fall in sales would cut profit by about 55.9%.
- Business implication
- The higher the leverage, the more profit swings with sales: more reward when sales rise, more risk when they fall.
Outsource the packing: break-even, margin of safety and operating leverage
Break-even quantity IB
- Given
- Fixed costs per month: $25,600
- Selling price per bag: $24.00
- Variable cost per bag: $14.90
- Formula
- Break-even quantity = fixed costs ÷ contribution per unit
- Substitution
- = $25,600 ÷ ($24.00 − $14.90)
- Working
- Contribution per unit = 24.00 − 14.90 = 9.1025,600.00 ÷ 9.10 = 2,813.19
- Answer
- 2,814 bags
Rounded up, not to the nearest whole number: at 2,813 bags the result would be a loss of $1.70.
- Unit
- bags per month
- Interpretation
- Outsource the packing covers every cost from 2,814 bags a month.
- Business implication
- A lower break-even leaves more room for sales to fall before a loss.
Margin of safety IB
- Given
- Forecast sales per month: 3,600 bags
- Fixed costs per month: $25,600
- Selling price per bag: $24.00
- Variable cost per bag: $14.90
- Formula
- Margin of safety = forecast (or actual) output − break-even output
- Substitution
- = 3,600 − ($25,600 ÷ ($24.00 − $14.90))
- Working
- Break-even output = 25,600.00 ÷ 9.10 = 2,813.19, rounded up to 2,8143,600 − 2,814 = 786As a share of forecast sales: 786 ÷ 3,600 × 100 = 21.8%
- Answer
- 786 bags
Sales could fall by 786 bags (21.8%) before the business makes a loss.
- Unit
- bags per month
- Interpretation
- Sales could fall by 786 bags before Outsource the packing makes a loss.
- Business implication
- The margin of safety is the cushion against a forecast that proves too high.
Degree of operating leverage IB HL
- Given
- Total contribution at 3,600 bags: $32,760
- Profit at the forecast: $7,160
- Formula
- Degree of operating leverage = total contribution ÷ profit
- Substitution
- = 32,760.00 ÷ 7,160.00
- Working
- 32,760.00 ÷ 7,160.00 = 4.5754
- Answer
- 4.58
The guide names operating leverage in 5.6 (HL) but gives no formula; this is the standard one the platform’s notes use.
- Unit
- a multiple: the per cent change in profit for each 1% change in sales
- Interpretation
- A 10% fall in sales would cut profit by about 45.8%.
- Business implication
- The higher the leverage, the more profit swings with sales: more reward when sales rise, more risk when they fall.
The indifference volume
Indifference volume Beyond the IB course
- Given
- Selling price per bag: $24.00
- Automate the packing: fixed costs per month: $31,625
- Automate the packing: variable cost per bag: $13.30
- Outsource the packing: fixed costs per month: $25,600
- Outsource the packing: variable cost per bag: $14.90
- Formula
- Indifference volume = (fixed costs of A − fixed costs of B) ÷ (contribution per unit of A − contribution per unit of B)
- Substitution
- = (31,625.00 − 25,600.00) ÷ (10.70 − 9.10)
- Working
- Contribution per bag: Automate the packing $24.00 − $13.30 = $10.70; Outsource the packing $24.00 − $14.90 = $9.106,025.00 ÷ 1.60 = 3,765.63
- Answer
- 3,765.63 bags
At this volume the two earn the same profit. Above it, Automate the packing, with the higher contribution per bag, earns more; below it, Outsource the packing, with the lower fixed costs, does.
- Unit
- bags per month
- Interpretation
- The two earn the same profit at 3,765.6 bags a month.
- Business implication
- Choose Automate the packing only if sales are expected to stay above 3,766 bags.
Section 04: What it means
For the figures above: the reading, what a manager might weigh, and where break-even analysis stops.
The reading
Automate the packing has the higher contribution per bag and the higher fixed costs, so it earns more only when volume is high enough to spread those costs: above 3,765.6 bags a month. Below that, Outsource the packing earns more.
At the forecast of 3,600 bags, Outsource the packing earns $265 a month more. Sales would have to rise by 4.6% before Automate the packing earned more.
Risk differs as well as profit. At the forecast, Automate the packing has a degree of operating leverage of 5.59 against 4.58: a 10% fall in sales would cut its profit by about 55.9%, against 45.8%. Its margin of safety is 17.9% of forecast sales, against 21.8%. The two measures tell the same story: worked with the exact break-even volume, before rounding up, the degree of operating leverage is one divided by the margin of safety as a share of sales.
What a manager might weigh
The platform’s suggestions, not IB requirements.
- Test the sales forecast before committing: the decision turns on whether sales stay below 3,766 bags, so ask how confident the business is, and for how many years.
- Weigh flexibility: fixed costs are hard to cut if demand falls, while variable costs fall with it. A business with uncertain demand may accept a higher cost per unit for the lower risk.
- Look beyond one period: an investment that raises fixed costs usually needs finance, and its interest is not in these break-even figures; the integrated forecast includes it.
- Count what is not in the numbers: control of quality and delivery, the staff affected, dependence on one supplier, and the time and attention each option takes.
Where break-even analysis stops
- It assumes a price and a variable cost per unit that stay the same at every volume, fixed costs that are fixed over the whole range, and that everything made is sold.
- Fixed costs are fixed only within a range: beyond capacity a business needs another machine or another shift, and the costs step up.
- The degree of operating leverage holds only near the volume it is worked at, and has no meaning at or below break-even.
- The indifference volume compares profit in one period. It leaves out the investment the higher fixed costs may need, its finance and how long it lasts; the integrated forecast and the capital budgeting comparator take those in.
Section 05: Where the IB course stops
What this tool takes from the IB course, and what it adds beyond it.
IB What the IB course uses
- 5.5 Break-even analysis SL and HL Contribution, the break-even quantity, the margin of safety, and the effects of changes in price or cost, by chart and by calculation. Guide, p. 34
- 5.6 Production planning HL only Operating leverage, named in the guide without a formula; cost to make against cost to buy. Guide, p. 34
- Toolkit: contribution HL only Contribution, a toolkit tool that includes make or buy analysis. Toolkit, p. 14
Beyond the IB course What this tool adds
- Comparing two whole cost structures side by side at the same price.
- The indifference volume: the volume at which the two earn the same profit, and which earns more on either side of it.
- The degree of operating leverage as a formula (total contribution ÷ profit), and its link to the margin of safety.
The course’s content is described in the platform’s words from the Business management guide (first assessment 2024), checked against the guide on 29 October 2026; see the claims register. The formulas the guide gives are on the formula sheet. Nothing on this page is an IB method unless it is marked IB, and no question here is an IB question.
Section 06: Sources
The method rests on standard references, cited here and in the source register. They were not opened for this release; the explanations are the platform’s own.
- Principles of Corporate Finance, 13th edition Richard A. Brealey, Stewart C. Myers and Franklin Allen, McGraw-Hill Education, 2020
- Business management guide, first assessment 2024 (published February 2022, updated May 2022) International Baccalaureate Organization, 2022
- How the advanced mode's example figures were built Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, 2026
Section 07: The IB parts, worked on their own
The Financial Laboratory and the Finance Desk work the parts the IB course uses, with the guide’s formulas and layouts.
- Laboratory Break-even quantity IB 5.5, SL and HL. How many units must be sold before every cost is covered?
- Laboratory Margin of safety IB 5.5, SL and HL. How far can sales fall before the business makes a loss?
- Laboratory Contribution per unit and total contribution IB 5.5, SL and HL. What does each sale add towards fixed costs and profit?
- On a case Break-even workspace (Atelier Barro) The same ideas worked on a fictional case at the Finance Desk.
- On a case Contribution decisions (HL) The same ideas worked on a fictional case at the Finance Desk.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/finance-desk/advanced/break-even-scenarios/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.