Revision sheet · Unit 2: Human resource management
2.3 Leadership and management
The decision What kind of leadership does this team need now?
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Key points
- The classic functions of management are planning, organizing, commanding (directing), coordinating and controlling.
- Management copes with complexity; leadership copes with change. Most people in charge have to do both.
- Autocratic leaders decide alone; paternalistic leaders decide alone in what they see as the staff's interest; democratic leaders consult; laissez-faire leaders leave decisions to the team.
- Situational leadership adapts the style to the task and to the readiness of the people.
- HL only: labour turnover = (employees leaving ÷ average number of employees) × 100.
- At HL, scientific decision-making analyses data before deciding; intuitive decision-making relies on experience and judgement.
- Different workplaces create different situations: urgent, high-stakes work favours a decisive leader in the moment, expert and changing work favours democratic or laissez-faire leadership, and new staff on routine tasks need direction.
- Leadership reaches beyond the team: customers, clients, owners and regulators all feel how a team is led, so judge a style by its effects on them too.
Common examination mistakes
-
Naming a style without explaining why it fits the situation in the case.
-
Treating paternalistic leadership as democratic because the leader is kind.
-
Recommending one style for a whole organization when the evidence shows different teams with different needs.
-
Analysing a leadership style only for the team, and ignoring its effects on customers, owners and clients.
-
“Managing is mainly about controlling people.”
Instead: Control is one function of five, and it is the last. A manager who only controls, measuring and correcting without planning, organizing or coordinating, is reacting to problems that the other functions would have prevented.
-
“Leaders and managers are different people.”
Instead: They are different jobs, not different people. Most people in charge of others have to do both: run today's work reliably and lead people through change. Amara's problem needs both at once.
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 2.3, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Autocratic leadership
- A style in which the leader makes decisions alone and tells others what to do.
- Democratic leadership
- A style in which the leader involves employees in decisions, consulting them and taking account of their views.
- Functions of management
- The classic list of what managers do, from Henri Fayol, planning, organizing, commanding (directing), coordinating and controlling.
- Intuitive decision-making HL
- Making a decision on judgement, experience and instinct, without a formal process of gathering and analysing data.
- Labour turnover HL
- The share of a workforce that leaves in a period, calculated as the number of employees leaving divided by the average number employed, multiplied by 100.
- Laissez-faire leadership
- A style in which the leader sets few rules and leaves most decisions to the team.
- Leadership
- Influencing and motivating people to work towards a shared goal, often through vision, example and trust rather than through position alone.
- Management
- Getting work done through other people by planning, organizing, directing and controlling resources towards an organization's objectives.
- Paternalistic leadership
- A style in which the leader makes decisions alone, in what they see as the employees' interest, and takes care of their welfare.
- Scientific decision-making HL
- Making a decision through a logical process of gathering and analysing data, setting out the options and choosing on the evidence.
- Scientific management
- Frederick Taylor's theory that every job has one most efficient method, found by observing, timing and measuring the work. It assumes that workers are motivated mainly by money, so pay should be tied to output.
- Situational leadership
- Adapting the leadership style to the task and to the readiness of the people being led.
- Stakeholder
- Any individual or group with an interest in what an organization does, because its decisions have an impact on them or because they can influence those decisions.
Formulae
Each with what it measures. The formula sheet shows which ones the examination provides.
| Formula | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Labour turnover = (number of employees leaving ÷ average number of employees) × 100 HL | The share of a workforce that leaves in a period, calculated as the number of employees leaving divided by the average number employed, multiplied by 100. |
Frameworks and tools
From the frameworks library: what each is for, a situation it suits, and one limitation.
-
Leadership styles IB syllabus
- Purpose
- To choose or evaluate a leadership style for a particular situation, and to explain why the same leader may need to lead differently at different times.
- Use it when
- Choosing how to lead a new team, or a team facing a crisis, such as a hotel opening with mostly new staff.
- One limitation
- Real leaders mix styles, and the categories simplify behaviour.
-
Force field analysis IB toolkit HL
- Purpose
- To analyse a planned change before committing to it, and to decide where effort will do most good.
- Use it when
- Planning a change at work that people may resist, such as a new shift pattern, a new system or a relocation.
- One limitation
- The scores are subjective, and the totals can give a false sense of precision.
-
Kotter's eight steps Enrichment
- Purpose
- To plan and lead large, planned changes, such as a merger, a new system or a new strategy, by setting out what leaders must do at each stage and in what order, and to diagnose why a change that is already under way has stalled.
- Use it when
- A large, planned change across an organization, such as a new records system in a group of clinics or a merger of two departments.
- One limitation
- It is linear and led from the top, which suits planned, one-off changes better than continuous or bottom-up change.
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- The new manager of Kilnworth Bakery's night shift finds an experienced, skilled team that dislikes being told how to work. Output and quality are already high.
Recommend a leadership style for the new night-shift manager at Kilnworth Bakery.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Reads the situation: an experienced, motivated team doing work it knows well.
- Recommends a democratic or laissez-faire style, with clear targets for output and quality, because the team can be trusted with decisions.
- Explains why an autocratic style would probably demotivate the team and add little.
- Uses situational leadership to say when the style should change, for example a firmer approach on safety or if quality slips.
- Kilnworth Bakery's night-shift manager plans rotas, orders flour, checks output against targets, and must also persuade the team to accept a new recipe system.
Distinguish between management and leadership, using the night-shift manager's role at Kilnworth Bakery.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Management: planning, organizing, directing, coordinating and controlling, such as rotas, orders and checking output.
- Leadership: setting a direction and winning people's commitment to it, such as bringing the team behind the new recipe system.
- Shows that the manager needs both, and that leadership matters most when things must change.
- Kilnworth Bakery's owner must decide by tonight whether to accept a large rush order from a new customer. She has little data, but twenty years' experience of what her bakery can do.
Explain why she might use intuitive rather than scientific decision-making.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Defines scientific decision-making as gathering and analysing data before deciding, and intuitive as relying on experience and judgement.
- The decision is urgent, data are scarce and the situation is familiar to an experienced decision-maker, which favours intuition.
- Notes the risk of bias or overconfidence, and that a quick check of capacity and ingredients would combine the two.
Answer from memory
8 recall questions from the 2.3 brief
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
Name the five classic functions of management.
Planning, organizing, commanding (directing), coordinating and controlling.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between paternalistic and democratic leadership?
A paternalistic leader decides alone, in what they see as the staff's interest; a democratic leader involves staff in the decision.
How well did you recall it? -
When does laissez-faire leadership work well?
With an expert, motivated team that works best with autonomy.
How well did you recall it? -
What is situational leadership?
Adapting the leadership style to the task and to the readiness of the people being led.
How well did you recall it? -
(HL) How is labour turnover calculated?
Number of employees leaving in a period, divided by the average number of employees, multiplied by 100.
How well did you recall it? -
When is intuitive decision-making most useful?
When the decision is urgent, the situation is familiar to an experienced decision-maker, or the data do not exist.
How well did you recall it? -
Why might an emergency department use autocratic leadership during an emergency and democratic leadership afterwards?
In the emergency, decisions must be made in seconds by someone with authority; in the review afterwards, everyone's view of what went wrong is needed to improve.
How well did you recall it? -
(HL) How does scientific thinking in 2.3 differ from Taylor's scientific management?
Scientific thinking is a way of making decisions on gathered and analysed data; Taylor's scientific management (2.4) is a theory of designing work, timing tasks and paying by output.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.