Revision sheet · Unit 2: Human resource management

2.4 Motivation and demotivation

SL and HL, with HL-only content 52 definitions · 2 formulae · 8 frameworks · 3 exercises
Read the full notes Flashcards for 2.4 (94)
Show content for

Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.

Key points

  • Motivation is the drive to put effort into a goal, and demotivation shows in absence, mistakes, complaints and resignations. Intrinsic motivation comes from the work itself, extrinsic motivation from rewards.
  • Taylor: people work mainly for money, so find the one best way, train workers in it, pay by piece rate and separate planning from doing. It raises output on simple, countable work but ignores social and psychological needs.
  • Maslow: physiological, safety, social, esteem and self-actualization needs, with the lowest unmet need driving behaviour, so the same reward motivates some people and not others. The order is not rigid.
  • Herzberg: hygiene factors, pay among them, prevent dissatisfaction but do not motivate, while motivators in the job itself, such as achievement, recognition and responsibility, do; hence job enrichment.
  • Financial rewards are salary, wages (time and piece rates), commission, performance-related pay, profit-related pay, employee share ownership schemes and fringe payments; the method of payment matters as much as the amount.
  • Non-financial rewards are job enrichment, job rotation, job enlargement, empowerment, purpose and teamwork. They act on intrinsic motivation but need trust, training and fair pay first.
  • Training is induction for new starters, on-the-job training in the workplace, or off-the-job training away from it.
  • (HL) McClelland: acquired needs for achievement, affiliation and power. Deci and Ryan: autonomy, competence and relatedness build autonomous motivation. Equity theory: perceived fairness compared with others. Expectancy theory: expectancy × instrumentality × valence.
  • (HL) Labour turnover = (number of employees leaving ÷ average number of employees) × 100, judged against the past, rivals and who is leaving. Appraisal is formative, summative, 360-degree or self-appraisal, and recruitment internal or external, each with its trade-offs.

Common examination mistakes

  1. “Everyone is motivated by the same things.”

    Instead: People differ in their needs and values, and the same person's motivation changes over their career and circumstances.

    Glossary: Motivation

  2. “Scientific management is out of date and no longer used.”

    Instead: Its methods live on in time-and-motion study, standard operating procedures, call-centre targets and data-driven monitoring, which the guide calls digital Taylorism.

    Glossary: Scientific management

  3. “People must fully satisfy one level before the next matters.”

    Instead: Maslow himself saw the levels as overlapping and partly satisfied at once; people can seek esteem while still worried about security.

    Glossary: Maslow's hierarchy of needs

  4. Dividing by the number of employees at the end of the year instead of the average. HL

    Calculation: Labour turnover

  5. Treating equity as equal pay. HL

    Instead: Compare ratios of outcomes to inputs, and say which inputs, such as experience, people believe should count.

    Equity theory

  6. Adding the three beliefs instead of multiplying them. HL

    Instead: Multiply: a near-zero belief in any one of them leaves the whole near zero, which is the theory's central point.

    Expectancy theory

Key definitions

The IB glossary terms of 2.4, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.

360-degree feedback HL
Appraisal that gathers feedback on an employee from people all around them at work, such as their manager, colleagues, subordinates and sometimes customers, often alongside their own self-assessment.
Appraisal HL
A structured review of how well an employee is performing against agreed objectives, used to give feedback, identify training needs, set new targets and inform decisions on pay and promotion.
Autonomy HL
In self-determination theory, the need to feel in control of one's own actions and to act by choice rather than under pressure.
Commission
Pay calculated as a percentage of the value of the sales an employee makes, often on top of a basic salary.
Competence HL
In self-determination theory, the need to feel capable and effective in what one does and to master challenges.
Demotivation
A fall in an employee's drive to work well, shown in less effort, poorer quality, more absence and lateness, and a greater wish to leave.
Employee share ownership scheme
A scheme that gives employees shares in the company they work for, either free or at a reduced price, often on condition that they keep them for a period.
Empowerment
Giving employees the authority, resources and confidence to make decisions about their own work without having to ask a manager first.
Equity theory HL
J. S. Adams's theory that employees compare what they put into a job (inputs such as effort, skill and time) and what they get from it (outcomes such as pay, recognition and promotion) with the same balance for other people, and are motivated when they see the exchange as fair.
Expectancy HL
In Vroom's expectancy theory, a person's belief that putting in effort will lead to the required level of performance.
Expectancy theory HL
Victor Vroom's theory that motivation depends on three beliefs: that effort will lead to good performance (expectancy), that good performance will be rewarded (instrumentality) and that the reward is worth having (valence).
External recruitment HL
Filling a vacancy with someone from outside the organization, found through methods such as job advertisements, online job sites and social media, recruitment agencies, headhunting, job fairs and referrals.
Extrinsic motivation
Motivation that comes from outside the work, from rewards such as pay, bonuses, praise and promotion, or from the wish to avoid a penalty.
Financial rewards
Payments made to employees in money, or with a clear money value, including salary, wages, commission, performance-related pay, profit-related pay, employee share ownership schemes and fringe payments.
Formative appraisal HL
Ongoing appraisal during a period of work that gives regular feedback to help the employee improve, rather than to judge final results.
Fringe payments
Rewards given to employees in addition to their pay, such as a company car, health insurance, pension contributions, staff discounts, subsidized meals or gym membership.
Herzberg's motivation-hygiene theory
Frederick Herzberg's theory that the factors that cause job dissatisfaction (hygiene factors) are different from those that cause satisfaction and motivation (motivators), so removing dissatisfaction does not on its own motivate people.
Hygiene factors
In Herzberg's theory, the factors surrounding a job, such as pay, working conditions, job security, supervision, relationships at work and company policy, that cause dissatisfaction when they are poor but do not motivate when they are good.
Induction
Training that introduces new employees to the organization, its people, procedures, facilities, culture and health and safety rules, and to their own job.
Instrumentality HL
In Vroom's expectancy theory, a person's belief that good performance will actually be rewarded.
Internal recruitment HL
Filling a vacancy with someone who already works for the organization, by promotion, transfer or redeployment.
Intrinsic motivation
Motivation that comes from the work itself, because it is interesting, enjoyable, challenging or meaningful, rather than from a reward attached to it.
Job description HL
A document setting out a job's title, purpose, main duties and responsibilities, whom the job holder reports to and the working conditions.
Job enlargement
Adding more tasks of a similar level of difficulty to a job, so that it has more variety but no more responsibility.
Job enrichment
Redesigning a job to give the employee more responsibility, more challenging tasks and a complete piece of work, so that they use more of their abilities.
Job rotation
Moving employees between different tasks or jobs at a similar level at regular intervals.
Labour turnover HL
The share of a workforce that leaves in a period, calculated as the number of employees leaving divided by the average number employed, multiplied by 100.
Maslow's hierarchy of needs
Abraham Maslow's theory that people are motivated by five levels of need, rising from physiological needs through safety, social (love and belonging) and esteem needs to self-actualization, and that a higher need motivates only once the lower ones are largely met.
McClelland's acquired needs theory HL
David McClelland's theory that motivation is shaped by three needs, for achievement, affiliation and power, which people acquire through their experience of life, so that one of them is usually dominant in each person.
Motivation
The drive that makes a person put effort into reaching a goal. It may come from the work itself (intrinsic motivation) or from rewards and pressures outside it (extrinsic motivation).
Motivators
In Herzberg's theory, the factors in the content of a job, namely achievement, recognition, the work itself, responsibility, advancement and personal growth, that create satisfaction and motivation.
Need for achievement HL
In McClelland's theory, the drive to succeed at challenging tasks through one's own effort and to do things better than before.
Need for affiliation HL
In McClelland's theory, the desire to be liked and accepted by others and to have close, friendly relationships at work.
Need for power HL
In McClelland's theory, the desire to influence, direct or control other people and to make an impact.
Non-financial rewards
Ways of motivating employees that do not involve money, such as job enrichment, job rotation, job enlargement, empowerment, purpose (the opportunity to make a difference) and teamwork.
Off-the-job training
Training that takes place away from the employee's normal work, such as courses, college programmes, conferences, workshops or online learning.
On-the-job training
Training given while the employee does the job in the normal workplace, for example by watching and copying an experienced colleague, coaching, mentoring or job rotation.
Performance-related pay
Extra pay, such as a bonus or a higher pay rise, given to employees whose performance meets or beats agreed targets, usually judged at appraisal.
Person specification HL
A document setting out the qualifications, skills, experience and personal qualities needed in the person who will do a job, often divided into essential and desirable criteria.
Piece rate
A way of paying wages in which employees receive a fixed amount for each unit they produce, so that pay rises with output.
Profit-related pay
A bonus paid to employees out of the organization's profit, so that their pay rises and falls with how well the business does.
Purpose at work
The sense that one's work makes a positive difference to customers, colleagues, society or the environment, which can motivate in itself.
Recruitment
The process of filling a vacancy, from deciding what the job needs and attracting suitable applicants to choosing the best of them (selection) and making an offer.
Relatedness HL
In self-determination theory, the need to feel connected to other people, to care for them and to be cared for.
Salary
A fixed annual amount of pay, usually paid monthly, that does not change with the exact number of hours worked or the amount produced.
Scientific management
Frederick Taylor's theory that every job has one most efficient method, found by observing, timing and measuring the work. It assumes that workers are motivated mainly by money, so pay should be tied to output.
Self-appraisal HL
Appraisal in which employees assess their own performance against their objectives, usually before discussing it with their manager.
Self-determination theory HL
Edward Deci and Richard Ryan's theory that people have three basic psychological needs, for autonomy, competence and relatedness, and that meeting them builds intrinsic motivation and well-being.
Summative appraisal HL
A formal appraisal at the end of a period, such as a year, that judges and records an employee's performance against targets, often to decide pay, promotion or further action.
Teamwork
Organizing work so that employees cooperate in groups, sharing responsibility for a common goal.
Valence HL
In Vroom's expectancy theory, the value a person places on the reward that good performance will bring.
Wages
Pay calculated either by the hour or other period worked (a time rate) or by the amount produced (a piece rate), and usually paid weekly.

Formulae

Each with what it measures. The formula sheet shows which ones the examination provides.

Formula What it measures
Labour turnover = (number of employees leaving ÷ average number of employees) × 100 HL The share of a workforce that leaves in a period, calculated as the number of employees leaving divided by the average number employed, multiplied by 100.
Expectancy theory Motivational force = expectancy × instrumentality × valence HL Victor Vroom's theory that motivation depends on three beliefs: that effort will lead to good performance (expectancy), that good performance will be rewarded (instrumentality) and that the reward is worth having (valence).

Frameworks and tools

From the frameworks library: what each is for, a situation it suits, and one limitation.

  • Equity theory IB syllabus HL

    Purpose
    To understand reactions to pay, promotion and workload decisions, and to design reward systems that are, and are seen to be, fair.
    Use it when
    Predicting how existing staff will react when new recruits are hired on better terms, or when one team receives a bonus another does not.
    One limitation
    Perceptions of inputs, outcomes and referents are personal and hard to measure.
  • Expectancy theory IB syllabus HL

    Purpose
    To design and test incentive schemes, targets and promotion systems by checking each of the three beliefs, and to diagnose why a scheme is not working.
    Use it when
    Designing or repairing an incentive scheme, such as a sales bonus that nobody tries to earn.
    One limitation
    The three beliefs are hard to measure, and the multiplication is a model, not a calculation managers can do precisely.
  • Herzberg's motivation-hygiene theory IB syllabus

    Purpose
    To explain why pay rises and better conditions may stop complaints without raising effort, and to design jobs that motivate.
    Use it when
    Explaining why a pay rise ended complaints but did not improve performance.
    One limitation
    The research relied on people's accounts of good and bad times, which may lead them to credit themselves for success and blame conditions for failure.
  • Maslow's hierarchy of needs IB syllabus

    Purpose
    To analyse which needs a job or a workplace meets, and to choose rewards and job designs that address the needs that are not yet met.
    Use it when
    Diagnosing why recognition schemes fail for staff whose basic security is not met, such as care workers with unpredictable rotas.
    One limitation
    Research gives little support to a fixed order; people pursue several needs at once.
  • McClelland's acquired needs theory IB syllabus HL

    Purpose
    To match people to roles, goals and rewards that suit their dominant need, and to understand why the same incentive motivates one person and not another.
    Use it when
    Assigning people to roles and projects, such as giving a high achiever a demanding solo task with clear milestones.
    One limitation
    The needs are hard to measure reliably; judgements based on behaviour can be subjective.
  • Self-determination theory IB syllabus HL

    Purpose
    To design jobs, management styles and rewards that build lasting, high-quality motivation, and to explain why heavy monitoring or controlling incentives can backfire.
    Use it when
    Knowledge and service work, such as software support or design, where scripts and close monitoring undermine motivation.
    One limitation
    Autonomy can be harder to give in roles with strict safety or legal rules.
  • Taylor's scientific management IB syllabus

    Purpose
    To understand the oldest of the motivation theories the guide names, its assumption that pay is the main motivator, and why it still appears in workplaces that measure and reward output closely.
    Use it when
    Repetitive, measurable work where productivity is the main goal, such as picking in a warehouse or assembling standard parts.
    One limitation
    It treats people as motivated only by money, ignoring social and psychological needs.
  • Descriptive statistics IB toolkit

    Purpose
    To summarize business data, such as sales, survey results, absence or waiting times, so that it can be compared and used in decisions, and to choose the measure and the chart that represent it fairly.
    Use it when
    Summarizing weekly sales, waiting times or absence before setting stock levels, staffing or targets.
    One limitation
    A summary can hide important detail, and the wrong average can mislead.

Apply it

Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.

  1. Fictional Explain · AO2

    Quaymill Couriers raised its drivers' pay by 8% after many complaints. Six months later the complaints have stopped, but absence and delivery errors are unchanged.

    Explain, using Herzberg's theory, why the pay rise did not improve the drivers' performance.

    Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
    • Identifies pay as a hygiene factor: improving it removed dissatisfaction, which is why the complaints stopped.
    • Explains that hygiene factors do not motivate; motivators such as recognition, responsibility, achievement and the work itself do.
    • Applies this to routine driving, which offers few motivators, and suggests one, such as recognition for accuracy or more responsibility for a route.
    • May note a limitation: some drivers may still respond to money, especially if pay was low.
  2. Fictional Analyse · AO2

    Quaymill Couriers is considering paying its drivers a piece rate for each parcel delivered instead of an hourly wage.

    Analyse the advantages and disadvantages of paying Quaymill's drivers a piece rate.

    Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
    • Advantages: pay is linked to output, so drivers have a reason to work quickly, and the cost per parcel is controlled.
    • Disadvantages: speed may come before care and safety, with more damaged parcels and accidents; pay becomes uncertain, which may raise labour turnover.
    • Links the idea to Taylor's scientific management and its view that money motivates.
    • Notes what would make it work, such as checks on quality and a guaranteed minimum.
  3. Fictional Calculate · AO4 HL

    Quaymill Couriers employed 150 drivers at the start of the year and 130 at the end. During the year 42 drivers left.

    Calculate the labour turnover for Quaymill's drivers, and comment on what it suggests.

    Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
    • Average number of drivers = (150 + 130) ÷ 2 = 140.
    • Labour turnover = (42 ÷ 140) × 100 = 30%.
    • Comments that almost a third of drivers leave each year, which brings recruitment and training costs, lost experience and weaker service.
    • Notes that the figure needs comparing with earlier years and other courier firms before it is judged high, and may point to problems with pay or conditions.

Answer from memory

12 recall questions from the 2.4 notes

Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.

  1. What did Taylor assume motivates workers, and which method of payment did he recommend?

    Money. He assumed workers want to earn as much as they can and will otherwise do as little as possible, so he recommended piece rates, which pay for each unit produced.

    How well did you recall it?
  2. Name Maslow's five levels of need, starting from the bottom.

    Physiological, safety, social (love and belonging), esteem and self-actualization.

    How well did you recall it?
  3. According to Herzberg, why might a pay rise stop complaints without increasing effort?

    Pay is a hygiene factor. Improving it removes dissatisfaction but does not motivate; motivation comes from motivators in the job itself, such as achievement, recognition and responsibility.

    How well did you recall it?
  4. What is the difference between job enrichment and job enlargement?

    Job enrichment adds responsibility and more challenging tasks. Job enlargement adds more tasks at the same level, so the job has more variety but no more responsibility.

    How well did you recall it?
  5. What is the difference between commission and profit-related pay?

    Commission is a percentage of the value of the sales an individual makes. Profit-related pay is a share of the whole organization's profit, so it depends on how well the business does, not on one person's results.

    How well did you recall it?
  6. Distinguish between on-the-job and off-the-job training.

    On-the-job training happens while doing the job in the normal workplace, for example working beside an experienced colleague. Off-the-job training happens away from normal work, for example on a course or at a college.

    How well did you recall it?
  7. What is induction, and why does it matter?

    Training that introduces new employees to the organization, its people, rules and procedures and their job. It helps them become productive sooner and makes them less likely to leave in their first months.

    How well did you recall it?
  8. (HL) Name McClelland's three acquired needs and Deci and Ryan's three basic needs.

    McClelland: achievement, affiliation and power. Deci and Ryan: autonomy, competence and relatedness.

    How well did you recall it?
  9. (HL) Using expectancy theory, explain why a large bonus might fail to motivate.

    Motivation depends on expectancy × instrumentality × valence. If staff think the target cannot be reached, doubt that the bonus will be paid, or do not value it, one of the three is close to zero, and so is motivation.

    How well did you recall it?
  10. (HL) A firm employed 120 people at the start of the year and 140 at the end, and 26 left during the year. Calculate labour turnover.

    Average number of employees = (120 + 140) ÷ 2 = 130. Labour turnover = (26 ÷ 130) × 100 = 20%.

    How well did you recall it?
  11. (HL) Give one advantage and one disadvantage of internal recruitment.

    Advantage: for example it is quicker and cheaper, the candidate is known, and promotion motivates other staff. Disadvantage: for example the pool is small, no new ideas come in, colleagues passed over may resent it, and it leaves another vacancy.

    How well did you recall it?
  12. (HL) What is 360-degree feedback?

    Appraisal that gathers feedback on an employee from people all around them at work, such as their manager, colleagues, the people they manage and sometimes customers, often with their own self-assessment.

    How well did you recall it?

Reveal and rate each card.

Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.