Revision sheet · Unit 2: Human resource management
2.2 Organizational structure
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Key points
- An organizational structure sets out who does which job, who reports to whom and who decides what; an organization chart shows the formal structure only, not the informal networks.
- The guide's terms: levels of the hierarchy, span of control (direct reports to one manager), chain of command, delegation (passing authority for a task while staying accountable), centralization and decentralization (where decisions are made), bureaucracy (rules, procedures and defined roles) and delayering (removing levels).
- For the same number of people, wider spans mean fewer levels. Tall structures have many levels and narrow spans; flat structures have few levels and wide spans.
- Charts group work by function, by product or by region; large organizations often combine them, and the grouping should follow the strategy.
- In a matrix structure employees answer to a functional manager and a project manager at once, which brings skills together but divides authority.
- The guide sets organization charts at AO4 as well as AO2: be ready to construct one from a description and to count its levels and spans.
- No structure is best in general. Choose the one that fits what a change in external factors demands, whether speed, control, local knowledge, flexibility or lower cost, and weigh it against the cost of changing.
- (HL) Project-based organization builds temporary teams from several functions around each project; Handy's Shamrock Organization has a professional core, a contractual fringe and a flexible labour force, gaining flexibility at the cost of loyalty and security.
Common examination mistakes
-
“When a manager delegates a task, the manager is no longer responsible for it.”
Instead: Authority is passed down, but the manager remains accountable for the result.
-
“A wide span of control is always more efficient.”
Instead: It cuts management costs, but if staff need close support, quality and morale can suffer.
-
“More levels of hierarchy always mean more control.”
Instead: Each layer adds a step where messages can be delayed or distorted, which can weaken control from the top.
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 2.2, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Bureaucracy
- A way of organizing based on formal rules, written procedures, clearly defined roles and a hierarchy of authority, in which decisions follow set approval processes.
- Centralization
- Keeping decision-making authority with a small group of senior managers, usually at head office, rather than passing it down to lower levels or local units.
- Chain of command
- The formal line of authority through which instructions pass down an organization and accountability passes up, from the top of the hierarchy to the bottom.
- Contractual fringe HL
- In Handy's Shamrock Organization, the outside individuals and firms contracted to do work that is not central to the organization, paid for results rather than for the time they spend.
- Decentralization
- Passing decision-making authority from the centre to lower levels of the hierarchy, or to regional and branch managers.
- Delayering
- Removing one or more levels of hierarchy, usually layers of middle management, to make a structure flatter.
- Delegation
- Passing the authority to carry out a task or make a decision to someone lower in the hierarchy, while the manager who delegates remains accountable for the result.
- Flat structure
- An organizational structure with few levels of hierarchy and wide spans of control.
- Flexible labour force HL
- In Handy's Shamrock Organization, the part-time, temporary and seasonal workers that an organization takes on when demand requires and lets go when it falls.
- Functional structure
- A structure that groups employees into departments by the work they do, such as marketing, finance, operations and human resources.
- Levels of hierarchy
- The number of layers of authority in an organization, from the most senior managers down to the employees with no one reporting to them.
- Matrix structure
- A structure in which employees report to two managers at once, usually the manager of their function, such as marketing or engineering, and the manager of the project or product they are working on.
- Organization chart
- A diagram of an organization's formal structure, showing its positions or departments, the lines of authority between them and the levels of the hierarchy.
- Organizational structure
- The way an organization arranges its jobs, departments and lines of authority, which sets who reports to whom, who makes which decisions and how information flows.
- Product-based structure
- A structure that divides an organization into units by product or product range, each usually with its own functional staff.
- Professional core HL
- In Handy's Shamrock Organization, the permanent, highly skilled staff, such as managers, professionals and technicians, whose knowledge and skills are essential to the organization.
- Project-based organization HL
- A way of organizing in which work is built around projects, each carried out by a temporary team drawn from different functions that disbands when the project is finished.
- Regional structure
- A structure that divides an organization into units by geographical area, such as countries or regions, each responsible for its own market.
- Shamrock Organization HL
- Charles Handy's model of an organization made of three groups of workers, like the three leaves of a shamrock: a professional core of permanent key staff, a contractual fringe of outside contractors and a flexible labour force of temporary and part-time workers.
- Span of control
- The number of subordinates who report directly to one manager.
- Tall structure
- An organizational structure with many levels of hierarchy and narrow spans of control.
Frameworks and tools
From the frameworks library: what each is for, a situation it suits, and one limitation.
-
The McKinsey 7S model Enrichment
- Purpose
- To diagnose why an organization is not performing, or to plan a change so that every element supports it.
- Use it when
- Diagnosing why a reorganization or a new strategy has stalled, such as product teams that still behave like branches because the bonus scheme was not changed.
- One limitation
- It describes how elements fit but does not say what the right state of each should be.
-
The RACI matrix Enrichment
- Purpose
- To make roles explicit in a project or a change, especially where people work across departments or report to two managers, so that tasks are not duplicated, dropped or argued over, and so that people are consulted and informed without slowing everything down.
- Use it when
- Projects where several people think they own the same decision, or where tasks fall between roles, such as opening a second café.
- One limitation
- It shows roles, not how well people work together; a clear matrix cannot fix a lack of trust.
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Larchway Insurance has seven levels of hierarchy between its chief executive and its call-centre staff. It plans to remove two levels of middle management.
Explain two possible effects of the delayering on Larchway Insurance.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Faster communication and decisions, with fewer levels for messages to pass through, and lower salary costs.
- Wider spans of control: remaining managers supervise more staff, so they may be overloaded and support may suffer.
- More delegation and responsibility can motivate staff; fewer levels also mean fewer chances of promotion.
- Considers the morale of those who remain after colleagues lose their jobs.
- Larchway Insurance is expanding into three new countries, each with its own laws, regulators and customer expectations.
Discuss whether Larchway Insurance should organize itself by region.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- For: regional managers can adapt products, prices and service to local law and customers, and respond quickly.
- Against: functions such as marketing and IT are repeated in every region, raising costs, and consistency across regions is harder.
- Considers the alternatives, such as a functional, product-based or matrix structure.
- Judges which suits, for example a regional structure while the new markets differ most, with some functions kept central.
- Sablewood Events keeps 20 permanent staff who plan and sell its events. For each event it hires stage crews by the day, and it contracts catering and security firms that are paid for the job.
Explain how Sablewood Events matches Charles Handy's Shamrock Organization.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- The professional core: the 20 permanent staff, whose skills and knowledge the business depends on.
- The contractual fringe: the catering and security firms, paid by contract for results.
- The flexible labour force: the stage crews, hired as each event needs them.
- Explains the benefit, lower fixed costs in a business whose work comes and goes, and a risk, such as weaker loyalty or uneven quality.
Answer from memory
8 recall questions from the 2.2 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
What is the difference between span of control and levels of the hierarchy?
Span of control is the number of people who report directly to one manager. Levels of the hierarchy are the number of layers of authority. For the same workforce, wider spans mean fewer levels.
How well did you recall it? -
How does delegation differ from decentralization?
Delegation passes a particular task or decision from one manager to a subordinate, while the manager stays accountable. Decentralization passes decision-making power down the whole structure, to lower levels, regions or branches.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two advantages and two disadvantages of a flat structure.
Advantages: for example faster communication, lower management costs, and more responsibility for staff, which can motivate. Disadvantages: for example overloaded managers, lighter supervision and fewer chances of promotion.
How well did you recall it? -
What is delayering, and what is one risk of it?
Removing one or more levels of the hierarchy, usually middle managers, to make a structure flatter. Risks include overloaded managers, fewer promotion steps, low morale after redundancies and lost experience.
How well did you recall it? -
Which grouping suits a business selling in many countries with different tastes and laws, and why?
Grouping by region, because regional managers can adapt products, prices and promotion to local conditions and respond quickly.
How well did you recall it? -
What is a matrix structure, and what is its main drawback?
Employees report to two managers at once, the head of their function and the manager of their project. The main drawback is conflict between the two managers' priorities, which causes confusion and divided loyalty.
How well did you recall it? -
Why might a business facing fast technological change flatten and decentralize its structure?
So that decisions are taken quickly and close to customers and problems, without waiting for approval to pass up and down a long chain of command.
How well did you recall it? -
(HL) Name the three parts of Handy's Shamrock Organization.
The professional core of permanent key staff, the contractual fringe of outside contractors paid for results, and the flexible labour force of part-time, temporary and seasonal workers.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.