Revision sheet · Unit 3: Finance and accounts
3.8 Investment appraisal
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Key points
- Investment appraisal compares a project's capital cost with its expected net cash flows, to accept or reject it or to rank competing projects.
- The payback period is the time the net cash flows take to add up to the capital cost. The months in the payback year are the amount still to recover ÷ that year's net cash flow × 12, assuming the cash arrives evenly.
- Payback rewards speed and limits risk, but ignores the returns after payback and the time value of money.
- ARR = ((total returns − capital cost) ÷ years of use) ÷ capital cost × 100, the guide's formula. Compare it with the cost of borrowing or a target rate.
- ARR uses every year's returns but ignores when they arrive, and other definitions of ARR exist, so use the guide's.
- (HL only) NPV = ∑ present values of return − original cost, where each present value is a year's return × the discount factor from the guide's table. The original cost is not discounted.
- (HL only) A positive NPV means the project earns more than the discount rate; a higher rate lowers every NPV, so the choice of rate can decide the result.
- The methods can rank projects differently, so use more than one, compare each result with a benchmark, test the forecasts with what-if questions, and weigh the qualitative factors before deciding.
Common examination mistakes
-
“The project with the shortest payback period is always the best.”
Instead: Payback ignores the returns after the cost is recovered, so a project that pays back more slowly may earn far more over its life.
-
“Any positive ARR means the project is worth doing.”
Instead: The ARR must beat what the money could earn elsewhere, such as the interest rate on a loan or a target rate; a small positive ARR may be worse than the alternatives.
-
“A positive NPV guarantees that the project will make a profit.” HL
Instead: NPV is only as reliable as the forecast returns and the discount rate; it shows that the project beats the chosen rate if the forecasts prove right.
-
Working out the months without assuming the year's cash arrives evenly, or without saying so.
-
Dividing total profit by the capital cost without first dividing by the years of use.
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 3.8, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Average rate of return (ARR)
- The average yearly net return from an investment, after its capital cost has been covered, as a percentage of that capital cost.
- Discount factor HL
- The number by which a future sum is multiplied to find its present value, which depends on the discount rate and on how many years away the sum is.
- Investment
- Spending money now on capital assets or projects, such as machinery, buildings, technology or research, in order to earn returns in the future.
- Investment appraisal
- Using quantitative methods (the payback period, the average rate of return and, for HL, net present value) to judge whether an investment project is worthwhile or which of several projects to choose.
- Net present value (NPV) HL
- The total present value of an investment's future returns, once each has been discounted, minus the project's original cost, which shows whether the project adds value in today's money.
- Payback period
- The time it takes for the net cash flows from an investment to add up to its capital cost, usually stated in years and months.
- Present value HL
- What a sum of money to be received in the future is worth today, found by multiplying it by the discount factor for its year and the chosen rate.
- Time value of money
- The idea that a sum of money received today is worth more than the same sum received in the future, because money held now can be invested to earn interest, and future money is less certain and can lose value to inflation.
Formulae
Each with what it measures. The formula sheet shows which ones the examination provides.
| Formula | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Payback period = years before the cost is recovered + (amount still to recover ÷ net cash flow in the payback year) × 12 months | The time it takes for the net cash flows from an investment to add up to its capital cost, usually stated in years and months. |
| Average rate of return (ARR) ARR = ((total returns − capital cost) ÷ years of use) ÷ capital cost × 100 | The average yearly net return from an investment, after its capital cost has been covered, as a percentage of that capital cost. |
| Net present value (NPV) NPV = sum of the present values of the returns − original cost HL | Whether the project adds value in today's money. |
| Present value = return in a year × discount factor for that year and rate HL | What a sum of money to be received in the future is worth today, found by multiplying it by the discount factor for its year and the chosen rate. |
| Discount factor = 1 ÷ (1 + r)ⁿ HL | The number by which a future sum is multiplied to find its present value, which depends on the discount rate and on how many years away the sum is. |
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Tarnbrook Cider is considering a bottling machine costing $80,000. It expects net cash flows of $30,000, $30,000, $24,000 and $16,000 in years 1 to 4, after which the machine will have no value.
Calculate the payback period and the average rate of return (ARR) for the machine.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- After two years $60,000 is recovered and $20,000 remains; ($20,000 ÷ $24,000) × 12 = 10 months, so payback is 2 years and 10 months.
- Total returns = $100,000; net return = $100,000 − $80,000 = $20,000, or $5,000 a year over four years.
- ARR = ($5,000 ÷ $80,000) × 100 = 6.25%.
- States the assumption that each year's cash arrives evenly through the year.
- Tarnbrook Cider's bottling machine pays back in 2 years and 10 months, with an ARR of 6.25%. The business could borrow at 7% a year, and its owners want to double output within five years.
Recommend whether Tarnbrook Cider should buy the bottling machine.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Sets the ARR of 6.25% against the 7% cost of borrowing: on this measure the machine looks weak, though ARR ignores when the cash arrives.
- Considers payback: under three years, so the cash risk is limited.
- Adds what the figures leave out: the reliability of the forecasts, capacity for the owners' growth objective, quality and the effect on staff.
- Gives a justified recommendation, for example to buy only if the machine is needed for the planned growth or can be financed without borrowing at 7%.
- Tarnbrook Cider's bottling machine costs $80,000 and returns $30,000, $30,000, $24,000 and $16,000 in years 1 to 4. At a discount rate of 10%, the guide's discount factors for those years are 0.9091, 0.8264, 0.7513 and 0.6830.
Calculate the net present value of the bottling machine at 10%, and explain what it shows.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Present values: $30,000 × 0.9091 = $27,273; $30,000 × 0.8264 = $24,792; $24,000 × 0.7513 = $18,031; $16,000 × 0.6830 = $10,928.
- Total present value = $81,024; NPV = $81,024 − $80,000 = $1,024.
- A positive NPV means the returns, discounted to today's money at 10%, are worth more than the cost, so on this measure the machine earns more than 10% a year.
- Notes how small the margin is, and that NPV and ARR can disagree because ARR ignores timing: most of these returns come early.
Answer from memory
8 recall questions from the 3.8 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
What does the payback period measure, and what does the usual method assume?
How long a project takes for its net cash flows to add up to its capital cost. Working out the months assumes that each year's cash arrives evenly through the year.
How well did you recall it? -
A $60,000 machine returns $20,000, $25,000 and $30,000 in years 1 to 3. What is its payback period?
After two years $15,000 is still to recover. 15,000 ÷ 30,000 × 12 = 6 months, so payback is 2 years and 6 months.
How well did you recall it? -
A $50,000 project has total returns of $70,000 over four years. What is its ARR?
(70,000 − 50,000) ÷ 4 = $5,000 a year; 5,000 ÷ 50,000 × 100 = 10%.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two limitations of payback and one of ARR.
Payback ignores the returns after payback and the time value of money, so it says nothing about profitability. ARR ignores when the returns arrive, and relies on forecasts for every year of the project's life.
How well did you recall it? -
Why might a business choose the project with the shorter payback, even though its ARR is lower?
For example because it is short of cash, its market or technology changes quickly, or its owners are cautious, so getting the money back quickly matters more than the highest average return.
How well did you recall it? -
HL only. Why is the original cost not discounted in an NPV calculation?
It is paid at the start, so it is already in today's money. Only the future returns are discounted.
How well did you recall it? -
HL only. What does a negative NPV at a 10% discount rate tell a business?
The present value of the returns is less than the cost, so the project earns less than 10% a year and, on financial grounds, should be rejected at that rate.
How well did you recall it? -
Name four qualitative factors in an investment decision.
For example fit with the business's objectives, the effect on employees, ethical and environmental effects, the brand, the reliability of the forecasts, the availability of finance and competitors' reactions.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.