Framework comparison
Payback, ARR and NPV
Which way of appraising an investment answers the question the business is really asking?
The guide's three methods of investment appraisal: how fast the money comes back, the average return it earns, and what the future cash is worth today. NPV is HL only.
Standing in the IB course
Payback period
IB syllabus 3.8 Investment appraisal: Investment opportunities appraised by payback period and average rate of return (ARR) (AO3, AO4); Business management guide, p. 30.
Key terms: Payback period, Investment appraisal
Average rate of return (ARR)
IB syllabus 3.8 Investment appraisal: Investment opportunities appraised by payback period and average rate of return (ARR) (AO3, AO4); Business management guide, p. 30.
Key terms: Average rate of return (ARR), Investment appraisal
Net present value (NPV)
IB syllabus 3.8 Investment appraisal: Net present value (NPV) (AO3, AO4), HL only; Business management guide, p. 30.
Key terms: Net present value (NPV), Discount factor, Present value, Time value of money
Purpose
Payback period
To find how long an investment takes to repay its cost from the net cash it generates.
Average rate of return (ARR)
To measure the average yearly profit an investment earns, as a percentage of its cost.
Net present value (NPV)
To value an investment's future net cash flows in today's money, and so whether it adds value after the cost.
Structure
Payback period
Add the net cash flows year by year until they equal the cost; with even flows within a year, the part year is the amount still to recover divided by that year's net cash flow, often given in years and months.
Average rate of return (ARR)
Total net returns minus the cost gives the total profit; divide by the number of years for the average yearly profit, then by the cost, times 100.
Net present value (NPV)
Multiply each year's net cash flow by the discount factor for that year at the chosen rate, add the present values, and subtract the cost. A positive NPV means the investment earns more than the discount rate.
The context it suits
Payback period
Businesses short of cash, risky or fast-changing markets, and any investment where getting the money back soon matters more than the total return.
Average rate of return (ARR)
Comparing projects of different sizes by their profitability, or checking a project against a target rate the business sets.
Net present value (NPV)
Long-lived investments where the timing of cash matters, and decisions that must account for the time value of money.
Strengths
Payback period
- Simple to calculate and to understand.
- Favours projects that return cash quickly, which reduces risk and helps liquidity.
- Useful where forecasts beyond a few years are unreliable.
Average rate of return (ARR)
- Uses all the returns over the project's life.
- A percentage, easy to compare with a target or with interest rates.
- Focuses on profitability, which owners care about.
Net present value (NPV)
- Accounts for the time value of money: cash received sooner is worth more.
- Uses all the cash flows over the project's life.
- Gives a clear rule: invest if the NPV is positive.
Limitations
Payback period
- Ignores all cash after the payback point.
- Ignores the timing of cash within the payback period, and the time value of money.
- Says nothing about how profitable the investment is over its life.
Average rate of return (ARR)
- Ignores the timing of returns: early and late cash count the same.
- Ignores the time value of money.
- Depends on estimates of returns far into the future.
Net present value (NPV)
- The result depends on the discount rate chosen, which is a judgement.
- Harder to calculate and explain than payback.
- Still rests on forecasts of future cash flows.
Common mistakes
Payback period
- Converting the part year into months wrongly, such as reading 0.4 of a year as four months.
- Using profit instead of net cash flow.
- Recommending the faster project without noting what it earns after paying back.
Average rate of return (ARR)
- Forgetting to subtract the cost before averaging.
- Dividing by the number of years twice, or not at all.
- Treating a high ARR as safe when most of the return comes in the final years.
Net present value (NPV)
- Forgetting to subtract the initial cost.
- Discounting the cost paid at the start, in year zero, which is already in today's money.
- Using the wrong year's discount factor, or a rate other than the one given.
A business application
Payback period
Fictional Saltmarsh Laundry Services
A laundry compares two washing machines. Machine A costs more but pays back in 2 years 6 months; machine B pays back in 3 years 2 months. With little cash to spare, the owners value the faster return.
Average rate of return (ARR)
Fictional Saltmarsh Laundry Services
Over five years, machine B returns more in total: its ARR is 18% against machine A's 14%. Machine A pays back sooner, but machine B is the more profitable over its life.
Net present value (NPV)
Fictional Saltmarsh Laundry Services
Discounted at 10% with the guide's printed factors, machine B's NPV is positive and higher than machine A's; at 20%, machine A's quicker returns give it the higher NPV. The choice depends on the rate the business should use.
In an examination answer
Payback period
Recommended strategy
Show the cumulative cash flow line by line and give the answer in years and months. Then interpret it against the business's situation (its cash, the risk) and add what payback leaves out, ideally with ARR beside it.
Average rate of return (ARR)
Recommended strategy
Set out the working: total returns, total profit, average yearly profit, then the percentage. Compare with the other project or a target, and note that ARR ignores timing, which payback captures: together they make a balanced judgement.
Net present value (NPV)
Recommended strategy
HL only, so it will not be needed in Paper 1, which leaves out HL-only material (guide, p. 43). Use the discount factors given, show each present value, and interpret the sign of the result. Evaluate by noting how the answer depends on the rate.
Section 01: The difference, in a paragraph
Payback measures speed: how quickly the cost comes back. ARR measures profitability: the average yearly return as a percentage of the cost. NPV measures value: what the future cash is worth today, after the cost, allowing for the time value of money. Payback and ARR are for SL and HL; NPV is HL only.
Section 02: Which to use when
-
The business is short of cash, or the market changes fast.
Use Payback period
Getting the money back quickly matters most, which payback measures.
-
The owners want to know which project earns the better return over its life.
Use Average rate of return (ARR)
ARR gives the average return as a percentage, comparable with a target.
-
A long-lived investment where cash in later years is worth less than cash now.
Use Net present value (NPV)
Only NPV allows for the time value of money.
Section 03: Using them together
Use them together: payback for risk and liquidity, ARR or NPV for profitability. A strong answer notes where they disagree and explains why, as in a fast-paying project with a lower return. The Finance Desk's investment appraisal desk works all three.
Section 04: Read more
In the course
Statements about the course come from the curriculum file, checked against the Business management guide (first assessment 2024); exam advice is the platform's own, labelled Recommended strategy; every business in the applications is fictional. Compare any two frameworks in the library.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/frameworks/compare/payback-vs-arr-vs-npv/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.