Financial Laboratory · Investment

Average rate of return (ARR)

What average yearly profit does a project earn on its cost?

Back to 3.8 Investment appraisal

  • IB 3.8 Investment appraisal
  • SL and HL
  • Formula as on the guide’s formula sheet
  • Simulated data Example: Emberly Roasters, fictional

As printed on the guide’s formula sheet (p. 65).

The calculator

Example figures: Emberly Roasters, a fictional business. Simulated data.

Your project

A negative figure is a year in which more cash goes out than comes in.

Currency

The labels, workings and results use these words. Emberly Roasters’s figures are in dollars.

The figures

Project
Nitrogen-flush packaging line
Capital cost (year 0)
$120,000
Net cash flow, year 1
$22,000
Net cash flow, year 2
$30,000
Net cash flow, year 3
$36,000
Net cash flow, year 4
$38,000
Net cash flow, year 5
$34,000

Changing these figures needs JavaScript. With it switched off, the page shows the full worked example for the figures above.

Result

These results are for the last complete figures. Correct the figure marked in the inputs to update them.

Average rate of return

6.67%

a year, on a capital cost of $120,000

Total returns
$160,000over 5 years
Total profit
$40,000total returns − capital cost
Average profit a year
$8,000.00
Capital cost
$120,000

Section 01: The formula and the working

Each formula in the guide’s words, then the working with the figures above, step by step.

Average rate of return (ARR) = ((total returns − capital cost) ÷ years of use) ÷ (capital cost) × 100

As printed on the guide’s formula sheet (p. 65).

Average rate of return

Given
  • Capital cost (year 0): $120,000
  • Net cash flow, year 1: $22,000
  • Net cash flow, year 2: $30,000
  • Net cash flow, year 3: $36,000
  • Net cash flow, year 4: $38,000
  • Net cash flow, year 5: $34,000
Formula
ARR = ((total returns − capital cost) ÷ years of use) ÷ capital cost × 100
Substitution
= ((160,000 − 120,000) ÷ 5) ÷ 120,000 × 100
Working
Total returns = 22,000 + 30,000 + 36,000 + 38,000 + 34,000 = 160,000
Total profit = 160,000 − 120,000 = 40,000
Average profit a year = 40,000 ÷ 5 = 8,000.00
8,000.00 ÷ 120,000 × 100 = 6.67
Answer
6.67%
Unit
per cent of the capital cost, per year
Interpretation
On average the project earns a profit of 6.67% of its cost each year.
Business implication
Compare it with the business’s target return and with the cost of the money that would pay for the project.

Section 02: The chart

Drawn from the figures above, with every value also in a table.

Yearly returns against the cost spread over the yearsNet cash flow by year: year 1 $22,000, year 2 $30,000, year 3 $36,000, year 4 $38,000, year 5 $34,000. The average return is $32,000 a year and the capital cost spread over 5 years is $24,000 a year, so the average profit is $8,000 a year.$0$10k$20k$30k$40kYear 1: net cash flow $22,0001Year 2: net cash flow $30,0002Year 3: net cash flow $36,0003Year 4: net cash flow $38,0004Year 5: net cash flow $34,0005Average return $32,000Cost a year $24,000YearNet cash flow each year
Chart Each year’s net cash flow, with the average return (dashed) and the capital cost spread evenly over the years (dotted). The band between the two lines is the average profit a year that the ARR divides by the cost.
The chart’s figures as a table
The returns behind the ARR
YearNet cash flow
Year 1$22,000
Year 2$30,000
Year 3$36,000
Year 4$38,000
Year 5$34,000
Average return a year$32,000.00
Capital cost spread over the years$24,000.00
Average profit a year$8,000.00

Section 03: If the estimates are wrong

The average rate of return when every year’s return, or the capital cost, is higher or lower than entered.

ARR under different estimates
EstimateARRTotal profit
Returns 20% lower1.33%$8,000
Returns 10% lower4.00%$24,000
As entered (the figures as entered)6.67%$40,000
Returns 10% higher9.33%$56,000
Capital cost 10% higher4.24%$28,000
Capital cost 10% lower9.63%$52,000

Reading. If every return came in 10% lower, the ARR would fall to 4.00%. The ARR is sensitive to the estimates because the profit it averages is the small difference between two large figures, total returns and the cost.

Section 04: What it means

For the figures above: the reading, the comparisons that give it meaning, and what a manager might do.

What the number means

On average the project earns a profit of 6.67% of its cost each year: $8,000.00 a year on $120,000. The ARR counts every year’s return equally, so $1 in year 5 weighs as much as $1 in year 1.

What to compare it with

Compare the ARR with the business’s target rate of return, with the interest rate on any loan that would pay for the project, with other projects competing for the money, and with the business’s return on capital employed: a project below the current ROCE would dilute the return on the business as a whole.

Why benchmarks vary

The return a business should require depends on risk and on the cost of money. A project in an unfamiliar market, or with uncertain sales, should promise more than a safe replacement of existing equipment, and when interest rates rise the bar rises with them. Because ARR ignores when the returns arrive, two projects with the same ARR can carry very different risks. Every method rests on estimates of future cash flows, which grow less reliable the further ahead they look.

What a manager might do

Options for a manager, not IB requirements; each has a cost or a risk to weigh.

  • Compare the ARR with a target the business sets in advance, not with a figure chosen after seeing the result.
  • Look at timing as well: a project whose returns come late is riskier than its ARR suggests; payback and, at HL, NPV show it.
  • Test the estimates: a 10% fall in every year’s return would take the ARR from 6.67% to 4.00%.
  • Weigh what the figures leave out before deciding: the fit with the business’s objectives, how risky the estimates are, and the effect on staff, customers and the environment.

Section 05: Learn more