Sirower (1997)
Synergy, premium and the buyer's gain
The buyer's gain equals the present value of synergies, net of integration costs, minus the premium over the target's stand-alone value and the costs of the deal. The premium is therefore a promise of improvements beyond those already priced into the target.
How to use it
Value the target alone, then value each synergy separately (cost, revenue and financial), each with its timing, probability and cost to achieve. Work out the improvement the premium requires, year by year, and compare it with what comparable deals have delivered. Test the result for a one-year delay and for revenue synergies of zero, which is how they often turn out.
Where it fails
Synergy estimates are made by people who want the deal, and the most valuable sources, such as new capabilities or growth options, are the hardest to value. The arithmetic shows when a price is too high, not whether integration will deliver.
Mark L. Sirower (1997). The Synergy Trap: How Companies Lose the Acquisition Game. Free Press.