Strategy Studio · Stage 3 of 4: Decide

Option appraisal and recommendation memo

Score strategic options against weighted criteria, see how far the ranking depends on the weights, and write the recommendation as a structured memo to copy or print.

Enrichment Not in the guide Worked example: fictional

What the tool is for, and its limits

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

Criteria and weights

What matters in this decision, and how much (0 to 5)? Agree the weights before you look at the totals.

Options

Two to five distinct options. Include doing nothing if it is a real choice.

Scores

Score each option from 1 (very poor) to 5 (very good) on each criterion.

Score each option from 1 (very poor) to 5 (very good) on each criterion
CriterionAFleet cargo bikes for delivery firmsBRelaunch commuter e-bikes onlineCCity bikes for dealers abroad
Expected profit over three yearsWeight 5; 5 means: Adds the most profit, on the decision tree and the forecasts
Fit with Northvale's strengthsWeight 4; 5 means: Builds on the cargo lead, the works and the dealers
RiskWeight 3; 5 means: The lowest risk
Cash neededWeight 3; 5 means: Needs the least cash
Effect on staff and dealersWeight 2; 5 means: Welcomed by staff and dealers
The memo

2. The options considered are taken from your options above, with what each involves.

The weighted scores and their sensitivity are added for you. One point per line.

One risk per line, with the response.

6. Implementation

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

The weighted ranking

Each option's weighted total: the sum of weight times score
RankOptionTotal% of maximumBar
1Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms64 of 8575%
2City bikes for dealers abroad54 of 8564%
3Relaunch commuter e-bikes online47 of 8555%

Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms ranks first with 64 points, 10 ahead of City bikes for dealers abroad. The ranking changes if the weight on expected profit over three years moves from 5 to 1 (City bikes for dealers abroad would lead). With equal weights, City bikes for dealers abroad and Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms would tie. The recommendation therefore rests on the weights: say why they are right for this business.

The working: weight times score
Weight times score for each criterion and option
CriterionWeightFleet cargo bikes for delivery firmsRelaunch commuter e-bikes onlineCity bikes for dealers abroad
Expected profit over three years55 × 5 = 255 × 3 = 155 × 2 = 10
Fit with Northvale's strengths44 × 5 = 204 × 2 = 84 × 3 = 12
Risk33 × 3 = 93 × 3 = 93 × 4 = 12
Cash needed33 × 2 = 63 × 3 = 93 × 4 = 12
Effect on staff and dealers22 × 2 = 42 × 3 = 62 × 4 = 8
Total17644754

The most an option could score is the sum of the weights times 5, which is 85. Weighted scoring is a decision-making method; it is not one of the guide's toolkit tools.

Checks

No problems found: the options are compared, the memo recommends the leading option, and its risks, steps and review are written.

The recommendation memo

Memo

To
The family board
From
Ingrid Marsh, managing director
Date
3 November 2026
Subject
How should Northvale Cycles restore its profit over the next three years?
Situation

Northvale's operating profit fell from €3.4m to €1.5m in two years. Direct-online brands undercut its commuter e-bikes, motor and battery prices rose 9%, and road and children's bikes lost €0.4m between them.

Its cargo e-bikes lead a segment that grew 22% last year, and three delivery firms have asked about fleets.

Options considered
  1. Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms. A fleet version of the cargo bike with service contracts, sold direct to delivery firms in low-emission cities, with a second assembly shift.
  2. Relaunch commuter e-bikes online. A cheaper commuter e-bike sold online with home delivery, to win back share from the direct-online brands.
  3. City bikes for dealers abroad. Sell city bikes through twelve dealers in a neighbouring country, with a local distributor.
Evaluation

Each option was scored from 1 to 5 against 5 weighted criteria: expected profit over three years (weight 5), fit with Northvale's strengths (weight 4), risk (weight 3), cash needed (weight 3) and effect on staff and dealers (weight 2). Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms scored 64 of 85 (75%); City bikes for dealers abroad scored 54 of 85 (64%); Relaunch commuter e-bikes online scored 47 of 85 (55%). Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms ranks first with 64 points, 10 ahead of City bikes for dealers abroad. The ranking changes if the weight on expected profit over three years moves from 5 to 1 (City bikes for dealers abroad would lead). With equal weights, City bikes for dealers abroad and Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms would tie. The recommendation therefore rests on the weights: say why they are right for this business.

SWOT: the heaviest factors are the lead in cargo bikes, costs above the online rivals, van restrictions in city centres and discounting by the online brands.

STEEPLE: the low-emission zones restricting vans score 20 of 25, the factor to act on first.

Five Forces (enrichment): the market for business cargo bikes is moderately attractive; buyer and supplier power are the strongest forces.

BCG matrix: city bikes are a cash cow in a shrinking market, and the cargo bike is the star that must replace them.

Decision tree: the fleet cargo bike has the highest expected value, €2.28m net of its cost, with a 0.2 chance of a loss.

Recommendation

Recommended: Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms.

It has the highest weighted score and the highest expected value, and it builds on what Northvale does best: its lead in cargo bikes, its own works and its dealers' servicing.

The ranking holds unless expected profit is given almost no weight. City bikes abroad is safer and cheaper, and is worth keeping as a second step once the fleet business is running.

Risks and how they will be managed

Weak fleet demand, a 0.4 chance in the decision tree: start with a paid trial, and cut the fleet price if orders lag.

Dealers opposing direct sales: pay them a commission on fleet sales in their area and use them for servicing.

Motor supply: qualify a second supplier before the second shift starts, as a contingency plan.

Staff resistance to a late shift: consult the staff council, ask for volunteers first and pay a shift premium.

Implementation
StepActionOwnerWhen
1Agree the plan, the budget and the review dates with the boardIngrid MarshDecember
2Run a paid three-month trial with one delivery firmHead of salesJanuary to March
3Agree a dealer commission on fleet salesHead of salesFebruary
4Qualify a second motor supplierOperations managerBy April
5Consult the staff council on a second shift, and recruit volunteersWorks managerMarch to May
6Launch to fleets in the three low-emission citiesIngrid MarshJune
What would change this recommendation

Think again if the trial wins fewer than 40 fleet orders, if the van charges are delayed beyond 2027, or if no second motor supplier can be found by April.

Drafted with the Strategy Studio, The Business Brief. The analysis supports a judgement; it does not make it.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To compare options on everything that matters to the decision, not only the figures, to test whether the ranking survives a change of priorities, and to turn the analysis into a recommendation that the people who must act on it can follow.

IB syllabus status

Enrichment Not in the guide

Weighted option appraisal is not in the guide's toolkit. It is a general decision-making method, offered as enrichment, like the weighted scoring of locations on the Operations Floor, and the memo's six parts are the platform's own structure. Reaching a reasoned recommendation is central to the course: Paper 3 (HL) asks for a recommended plan of action (Business management guide, pp. 42 and 47 to 50).

How to use it

  1. State the question, then list the criteria that matter and weight each from 0 to 5. Agree the weights before you look at the totals, and say what a score of 5 means, so that risk and cost are scored the right way round.
  2. List two to five distinct options, and score each from 1 to 5 on every criterion.
  3. Read the weighted ranking and the sensitivity test, which shows any weight at which a different option would lead, and who would lead if every criterion counted the same.
  4. Write the memo. The options and the weighted evaluation are filled in for you; add the situation, the evidence from your other tools (the button gathers the headlines of the tools you have saved), the recommendation, the risks, the implementation steps and what would change your mind.
  5. Copy the memo or print it. A recommendation that differs from the ranking is allowed, but the memo must say why.

Limitations

  • The scores and weights are judgements. A weighted total can make a judgement look more exact than it is.
  • Criteria can overlap and count the same thing twice, such as profit and return on investment.
  • A total can hide a fatal weakness. An option that scores 1 on legality or safety may need to be ruled out, whatever its total.
  • It compares the options listed, and cannot show a better one that nobody thought of.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to recommend, not to report the totals. Say which option, why, on what conditions, and what would change your mind, and let the sensitivity test tell you how hard to argue for the weights. Paper 3 (HL) ends with exactly this task, a recommended plan of action supported by the resource materials and by business management tools and theories (Business management guide, pp. 42 and 47 to 50).

Read alongside