Revision sheet · Unit 5: Operations management
5.8 Research and development
HL This subtopic is HL only. If you are taking SL, it is extension material.
Key points
- Research and development is systematic investigation (research) and the work of turning the results into new or improved products and processes (development). It covers processes as well as products, and services as well as goods.
- R&D is an investment, so its importance must be judged for the business. It matters most where technology and tastes change fast, rivals compete on innovation and patents on key products are expiring.
- Its rewards: new products to replace declining ones, a unique selling point and premium prices, lower costs from process R&D, new markets and licensing income. Its costs: high spending long before any revenue, uncertain outcomes, lower profit now and the risk of being copied.
- NPV can appraise an R&D project, but the forecasts are the weakest part, so test how far returns can fall before the NPV turns negative.
- Unmet needs can be known, which market research can find, or latent, which customers cannot express and which observation, data and R&D reveal. Latent needs can create new markets but carry more risk.
- Intellectual property protection lets a business recover the cost of R&D: a patent protects an invention for a limited period, copyright protects creative work automatically, and a trademark protects a brand and can be renewed indefinitely.
- Protection is territorial, costly to enforce and temporary, so secrecy, speed and brand strength also matter.
- Incremental innovation improves what exists in small steps; disruptive innovation creates or reshapes a market, usually entering from below, and displaces the leaders.
- Leaders often miss disruption by serving their best customers well; they can respond with a separate unit, an acquisition, a product that cannibalizes their own, or a balanced portfolio of R&D.
Common examination mistakes
-
Assuming that more spending on R&D guarantees successful innovation.
Instead: Judge how well it is spent: the link to customers' needs, the ability to bring ideas to market, and protection for what is created.
Recommended strategy
-
Mixing up patents, copyright and trademarks.
Instead: Patents protect inventions, copyright protects original works such as software and text, and trademarks protect brand names and logos.
Recommended strategy
-
Calling every new product a disruptive innovation.
Instead: Most innovation is incremental: better versions of existing products. Disruptive innovation starts with a simpler, cheaper offer for overlooked customers and later takes over the mainstream.
Recommended strategy
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 5.8, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Copyright
- The legal right of the creator of an original work, such as writing, music, film, artwork or software, to control how it is copied, shared and adapted.
- Disruptive innovation
- An innovation that creates a new market or transforms an existing one, often starting with a simpler or cheaper offer for customers that established businesses overlook, and in time displaces the market leaders.
- Incremental innovation
- A series of small improvements to an existing product, service or process, each building on the last.
- Innovation
- Turning a new idea into a product, service or process that people actually use, so that it adds value for customers or for the business.
- Intellectual property (IP)
- Creations of the mind, such as inventions, brand names, designs and creative works, that the law allows their owner to control, protect and sell.
- Latent need
- A need that customers have but are not aware of, or cannot put into words, until a product appears that meets it.
- Patent
- A legal right, granted by a government for a limited period, that lets the owner of a new invention stop others making, using or selling it without permission.
- Process innovation
- Developing a new or improved way of producing or delivering a good or service.
- Product innovation
- Developing a new or improved good or service to sell.
- Research and development (R&D)
- Systematic investigation and testing that a business carries out to create new products or processes, or to improve existing ones.
- Trademark
- A registered sign, such as a name, logo, slogan or sound, that identifies a business's goods or services and that others may not use without permission.
- Unmet need
- A need or want that existing goods and services do not satisfy, or do not satisfy well, which gives a business the chance to develop something new.
Formulae
Each with what it measures. The formula sheet shows which ones the examination provides.
| Formula | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Net present value (NPV) NPV = sum of the present values of the returns − original cost | Whether the project adds value in today's money. |
| Present value = return in a year × discount factor for that year and rate | What a sum of money to be received in the future is worth today, found by multiplying it by the discount factor for its year and the chosen rate. |
| R&D intensity = R&D expenditure ÷ sales revenue × 100 | How heavily a business invests in research and development, as a share of its revenue. A standard measure that the guide does not require. |
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Sorrelfield Hearing makes hearing aids. Its two larger rivals launch improved models every year, and Sorrelfield Hearing spends 2% of its revenue on research and development, against their 8%.
Discuss the importance of research and development for Sorrelfield Hearing.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- R&D matters most in fast-changing, technology-driven markets with short product life cycles, as here, so Sorrelfield Hearing risks falling behind.
- Benefits: new and better products, patents, premium prices and more efficient processes.
- Costs and risks: R&D is expensive and uncertain, and returns may take years; how well the money is spent matters as much as how much.
- Considers options such as focusing on one niche or working with a partner, and reaches a judgement.
- Sorrelfield Hearing has developed a new chip that filters out background noise, and sells its hearing aids under the name ClearHear.
Distinguish between a patent and a trademark, using Sorrelfield Hearing.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- A patent protects an invention, such as the new chip, for a limited period, in return for publishing how it works.
- A trademark protects a brand name or logo, such as ClearHear, and can be renewed indefinitely.
- Notes that copyright protects original works, such as Sorrelfield Hearing's software code and manuals.
- A start-up begins selling basic hearing aids online at a fifth of Sorrelfield Hearing's prices, aimed at people with mild hearing loss who have never bought one.
Explain why the start-up could be a disruptive innovation for Sorrelfield Hearing.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Disruptive innovation starts with a simpler, cheaper product for customers the leaders overlook, here people with mild hearing loss.
- Established firms often ignore it, because those customers are less profitable.
- As the product improves, it can win mainstream customers and displace the leaders.
- Contrasts it with incremental innovation, the yearly improvements Sorrelfield Hearing and its rivals make.
Answer from memory
12 recall questions from the 5.8 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
What is the difference between research and development?
Research is the search for new knowledge or the testing of ideas. Development turns that knowledge into products or processes that can be made, delivered and sold at a profit.
How well did you recall it? -
How is R&D different from market research?
Market research finds out what customers want and will pay for; R&D finds out what is technically possible and how to deliver it. Successful products usually need both.
How well did you recall it? -
Give three reasons why R&D can matter to a business.
For example, new products replace those in decline, a unique selling point supports premium prices, process R&D cuts costs, it opens new markets, and its intellectual property can be licensed for income.
How well did you recall it? -
Why do businesses under short-term pressure often cut R&D?
Because R&D reduces profit now while its benefits are uncertain and arrive years later, so cutting it raises this year's profit even though it weakens the business's future.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between a known need and a latent need?
Customers are aware of a known need and can describe it, so market research can find it. A latent need is one customers have but cannot express until a product meets it, so it is found by observation, data and R&D rather than by asking.
How well did you recall it? -
What does a patent protect, and roughly how long does it last in most countries?
An invention, a new and inventive product or process. In most countries a patent lasts up to 20 years, after which anyone may use the invention.
How well did you recall it? -
How does copyright differ from a patent in the way protection is obtained?
Copyright usually arises automatically when an original work is created, with nothing to register, while a patent must be applied for and granted.
How well did you recall it? -
Why can a trademark be more valuable in the long run than a patent?
A trademark can usually be renewed indefinitely while it is used, so the brand's protection can outlast every patent behind the product.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two limits of intellectual property protection.
For example, it applies only in the countries where it is granted, it is costly to enforce, patents expire, and a patent publishes the invention so rivals can design around it.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between incremental and disruptive innovation?
Incremental innovation makes small, continuous improvements to what already exists. Disruptive innovation creates a new market or reshapes an existing one, usually starting simple and cheap, and in time displaces the leaders.
How well did you recall it? -
According to Christensen, why do well-run leaders often miss disruptive innovations?
They focus on their best customers and on the improvements those customers want, and ignore small, low-margin markets, so each rational decision leaves room for a newcomer to grow from below.
How well did you recall it? -
An R&D project costs $100,000 and its returns have a total present value of $112,000. What is its NPV, and what does it suggest?
NPV = $112,000 − $100,000 = $12,000. It is positive, so on the forecasts the project is worthwhile, but the margin is small and the returns of an R&D project are uncertain.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.