Revision sheet · Unit 5: Operations management
5.4 Location
Showing everything. HL-only material is marked HL.
Key points
- Location is a long-term, costly and hard-to-reverse decision that affects costs, speed, quality and reputation.
- Quantitative factors can be measured in money, such as land, wages, transport, utilities, taxes, grants and tariffs; qualitative factors cannot, such as skills, infrastructure, nearness to customers and suppliers, stability, regulation, culture and community.
- Bulk-reducing processes locate near their materials; bulk-increasing and perishable ones, and services delivered in person, near their customers. Clustering and industrial inertia explain much of the rest.
- Weighted scoring, beyond the guide, combines factors into one total built from judgements, so test its sensitivity and look for fatal weaknesses.
- Outsourcing or subcontracting changes who does the work; offshoring changes where. Insourcing and reshoring reverse them.
- Outsourcing and offshoring cut costs and give access to specialists and markets, but they cost control and add hidden costs, risks and ethical exposure.
- Compare the full landed cost, not the headline price.
- Insourcing and reshoring regain control, speed and resilience, at the price of higher costs, investment and risk.
- Reorganizations are not permanent; they follow wages, freight costs, technology, trade rules and customers' preferences.
- A decision tree sets a location choice out as decisions and chance events; the expected value of an option is the sum of (probability × outcome) less its cost. It makes the assumptions explicit, but rests on estimates and leaves out qualitative factors.
- Services are reorganized too, nationally and internationally. Back-office work is the easiest to outsource or offshore; customer-facing work, where the service is the product, is the riskiest and the most often insourced again.
Common examination mistakes
-
“The expected value is the amount the business will actually earn.”
Instead: It is a weighted average of possible outcomes; the actual result will be one of the outcomes, not the average.
-
“If buying in is cheaper, the business should always buy.” HL
Instead: Cost is one factor; quality, reliability, control over know-how and what the freed capacity could do also matter.
-
“The expected value must be one of the possible outcomes.”
Instead: It is a weighted average, so it is often a figure that cannot actually happen.
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 5.4, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Bulk-increasing industry
- An industry whose finished products are bulkier or heavier than the materials used to make them, so it usually locates near its customers to keep transport costs down.
- Bulk-reducing industry
- An industry whose raw materials are bulkier or heavier than its finished products, so it usually locates near the source of those materials.
- Clustering
- The tendency of businesses in the same industry to locate close to one another, so that they share access to skilled workers, specialist suppliers, customers and ideas.
- Decision tree
- A diagram that sets out the options in a decision and the possible outcomes of each, with their probabilities and financial results, so that the expected value of each option can be calculated and compared.
- Expected value
- The average outcome of an option over many repetitions, found by multiplying each outcome's payoff by its probability and adding the results, then subtracting the option's cost.
- Industrial inertia
- The tendency of a business or an industry to stay in a location after the original reasons for choosing it have weakened or disappeared.
- Insourcing
- Taking back work that an outside firm had been doing, so that the business's own staff and facilities carry it out.
- Landed cost
- The total cost of a product once it has arrived where the buyer needs it, including the purchase price, transport, insurance, customs duties and handling.
- Location factors
- The influences on where a business decides to produce: quantitative ones that can be measured in money, and qualitative ones that cannot.
- Make-or-buy analysis HL
- A comparison of the cost of producing a good or component within the business with the cost of buying it from an outside supplier, used to choose between the two.
- Offshoring
- Carrying out an activity in another country instead of the home country, either at the business's own overseas site or through a foreign supplier.
- Outsourcing
- Paying another business to carry out an activity, or to make a product or part, that the business used to do, or could do, itself.
- Reshoring
- Bringing work that had been moved abroad back to the business's home country.
Formulae
Each with what it measures. The formula sheet shows which ones the examination provides.
| Formula | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Weighted score Weighted score of a site = the sum of (weight of each factor × the site's score on that factor) | One figure for an option that reflects how well it scores on each factor and how much each factor matters: each factor's weight times the option's score, added up. A standard technique, not one the guide names. |
| Expected value of an option Expected value = the sum of (probability × outcome) for each outcome − the cost of the option | The average outcome of an option over many repetitions, found by multiplying each outcome's payoff by its probability and adding the results, then subtracting the option's cost. |
Frameworks and tools
From the frameworks library: what each is for, a situation it suits, and one limitation.
-
Decision trees IB toolkit
- Purpose
- To compare options whose outcomes are uncertain, using numbers that can be questioned and tested.
- Use it when
- Choosing between a few options whose outcomes are uncertain but can be estimated, such as opening a second site or upgrading the first.
- One limitation
- Probabilities and payoffs are estimates, often guesses, so the precision can be false.
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Haverling Brewery has outgrown its city-centre site. It is choosing between a site on the edge of the city and one in a small town 60 km away, where land is much cheaper.
Explain two factors Haverling Brewery should consider when choosing its new location.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- The cost of land and buildings, much lower in the town.
- Access to customers: finished beer is heavy and bulky to transport, so being close to the city's pubs and shops matters.
- Labour: whether skilled brewers and current staff will work 60 km away.
- Others: water supply, road links, planning permission and incentives; explains each for a brewery.
- Haverling Brewery scores each site out of 10, weighting cost 0.5, access to customers 0.3 and labour 0.2. The city-edge site scores 4, 9 and 8; the town site scores 9, 5 and 5.
Comment on what a weighted score suggests about the two sites.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- City edge: (4 × 0.5) + (9 × 0.3) + (8 × 0.2) = 2 + 2.7 + 1.6 = 6.3.
- Town: (9 × 0.5) + (5 × 0.3) + (5 × 0.2) = 4.5 + 1.5 + 1.0 = 7.0, so the town site ranks higher.
- Comments that the weights and scores are judgements: giving access to customers more weight could reverse the ranking.
- Notes that weighted scoring is a standard technique rather than one the guide names, and that factors left out of it, such as staff willing to move, still matter.
- A bottling firm abroad offers to bottle Haverling Brewery's beer for 20% less than it costs Haverling Brewery to do it now. The beer would travel there in tankers and come back in bottles.
Discuss whether Haverling Brewery should offshore its bottling.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Makes clear that this is both outsourcing (another company) and offshoring (another country).
- For: lower bottling costs, a specialist's skills, and capital freed from bottling equipment.
- Against: transport both ways may wipe out the saving once the full landed cost is counted, plus slower supply, less control over quality, and a weaker local brand.
- Considers a local bottler instead, outsourcing without offshoring, and reaches a judgement.
Answer from memory
14 recall questions from the 5.4 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
Why are location decisions so important?
They are long-term, costly and hard to reverse, and they affect a business's costs, speed of delivery, access to staff, quality and reputation.
How well did you recall it? -
Distinguish between quantitative and qualitative location factors, with an example of each.
Quantitative factors can be measured in money, such as rent or wages. Qualitative factors cannot easily be, such as the skills of the local workforce or political stability.
How well did you recall it? -
Why do bulk-increasing businesses tend to locate near their customers?
Their products are heavier, bulkier or more perishable than their materials, so transporting the finished product is the larger cost.
How well did you recall it? -
What is industrial inertia?
The tendency of a business or industry to stay in a location after the original reasons for it have faded, because moving would lose its workforce, suppliers, reputation and existing buildings.
How well did you recall it? -
Two factors have weights of 3 and 2. Site X scores 8 and 5; site Y scores 6 and 9. Which has the higher weighted score?
Site X: 3 × 8 + 2 × 5 = 34. Site Y: 3 × 6 + 2 × 9 = 36. Site Y scores higher.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two limitations of weighted scoring.
For example, the weights and scores are subjective, the total gives false precision, a high total can hide a weakness that should rule a site out, and factors left out are ignored.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between outsourcing and offshoring?
Outsourcing changes who does the work (another firm); offshoring changes where it is done (another country). A move can be both.
How well did you recall it? -
Define insourcing and reshoring.
Insourcing brings work done by an outside firm back in-house; reshoring brings work done abroad back to the home country.
How well did you recall it? -
What is landed cost, and why does it matter?
The full cost of a bought-in product delivered to the business, including freight, duties, inspection and stock in transit. It shows the true saving from offshoring, which the supplier's price alone overstates.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two reasons why a business might reshore production.
For example, rising costs abroad, long and unreliable supply chains, quality problems, the need for faster response, protection of know-how, automation reducing the importance of wages, and customers who prefer local products.
How well did you recall it? -
Why is outsourcing riskier for core activities?
Core activities are what make the business distinctive; handing them to another firm loses control of the quality customers value and may share know-how with potential rivals.
How well did you recall it? -
A site costs $200,000. It returns $600,000 with probability 0.5 and $300,000 with probability 0.5. What is its expected value?
0.5 × $600,000 + 0.5 × $300,000 − $200,000 = $250,000.
How well did you recall it? -
Why is customer-facing work riskier to outsource than back-office work?
Customers experience it directly, so any fall in quality shows at once and harms the brand, while back-office work is unseen and easier to specify and check.
How well did you recall it? -
Give one strength and one limitation of a decision tree for a location choice.
For example, it sets out the options, risks and assumptions clearly and compares risky options on one measure; but its probabilities and values are estimates, and it leaves out qualitative factors.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.