Toolkit and decision tool HL only

Make-or-buy analysis

Where you meet this term: IB DiplomaUndergraduateMBAProfessional

A comparison of the cost of producing a good or component within the business with the cost of buying it from an outside supplier, used to choose between the two.

In plain words

Deciding whether it is cheaper and better for a business to make something itself or buy it from another business.

In more depth

The quantitative test compares the cost to make (fixed and variable costs that would actually be incurred) with the cost to buy (the supplier's price times the quantity). Relevant costs are those that change with the decision; shared overheads that remain either way are excluded. Qualitative factors, such as quality, reliability of supply, control, know-how and the use of freed capacity, often decide close cases.

Formula

Cost to buy = price per unit × quantity; cost to make = fixed costs + (variable cost per unit × quantity)

On the formula sheet, among the formulae to learn

In context

On cost alone, the business makes the item if the cost to make is lower than the cost to buy, but only costs that change with the decision should count: fixed costs that will be paid anyway are not saved by buying in. Qualitative factors often decide the matter, such as quality control, reliability of supply, spare capacity, protecting know-how and the effect on employees. It connects to cost to make and cost to buy in subtopic 5.6 and to outsourcing in 5.4.

Example

A bakery needs 10,000 boxes a month: buying them costs $0.30 each ($3,000), while making them needs a $1,200 machine lease plus $0.20 of materials a box ($3,200), so on cost alone it should buy them.

Common misconceptions

  • Misconception

    If buying in is cheaper, the business should always buy.

    In fact

    Cost is one factor; quality, reliability, control over know-how and what the freed capacity could do also matter.

Frameworks, tools and diagrams

Suggested next