Diagram · Unit 1 · 1.4

Stakeholders and one decision

SL and HL Fictional figures Switch between views

Choose a decision to see who gains, who loses and where they conflict.

The decision

Automate the packing line

Stakeholders and one decision: automate the packing line. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: automate the packing line. Shareholders: gains, lower costs raise profit. Managers: mixed, a cheaper line, but a hard change to lead. Employees: loses, 30 packing jobs go. Customers: gains, faster, more reliable orders. Suppliers: gains, machine makers win an order. Local community: loses, fewer local jobs. Government: mixed, more tax from profit, more people out of work. Pressure groups: mixed, less waste, but job losses. Conflicts: shareholders against employees; customers against local community. Owners and customers gain from lower costs; employees and the town lose jobs. The conflict is about who bears the cost of efficiency.Automate the packing lineINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Shareholders: gainsLower costs raise profit±Managers: mixedA cheaper line, but a hard change to lead−Employees: loses30 packing jobs goEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Customers: gainsFaster, more reliable orders+Suppliers: gainsMachine makers win an order−Local community: losesFewer local jobs±Government: mixedMore tax from profit, more people out of work±Pressure groups: mixedLess waste, but job losses+ gains, − loses, ± mixed. Dashed red arcs join the groups in conflict. Redwick Packaging is fictional.
Stakeholders and one decision: automate the packing line. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: automate the packing line. Shareholders: gains, lower costs raise profit. Managers: mixed, a cheaper line, but a hard change to lead. Employees: loses, 30 packing jobs go. Customers: gains, faster, more reliable orders. Suppliers: gains, machine makers win an order. Local community: loses, fewer local jobs. Government: mixed, more tax from profit, more people out of work. Pressure groups: mixed, less waste, but job losses. Conflicts: shareholders against employees; customers against local community. Owners and customers gain from lower costs; employees and the town lose jobs. The conflict is about who bears the cost of efficiency.Automate the packing lineINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Shareholders: gainsLower costs raise profit±Managers: mixedA cheaper line, but a hardchange to lead−Employees: loses30 packing jobs goEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Customers: gainsFaster, more reliable orders+Suppliers: gainsMachine makers win an order−Local community: losesFewer local jobs±Government: mixedMore tax from profit, morepeople out of work±Pressure groups: mixedLess waste, but job lossesConflicts: Shareholders againstemployees; Customers against localcommunity. Dashed boxes are inconflict.

Owners and customers gain from lower costs; employees and the town lose jobs. The conflict is about who bears the cost of efficiency.

Move the factory to a cheaper region

Stakeholders and one decision: move the factory to a cheaper region. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: move the factory to a cheaper region. Shareholders: gains, lower rent and wages raise profit. Managers: mixed, lower costs, but staff to recruit. Employees: loses, most cannot move with the jobs. Customers: mixed, lower prices, longer deliveries. Suppliers: loses, local suppliers lose the contract. Local community: loses, the old town loses jobs and spending. Government: mixed, jobs move from one region to another. Pressure groups: loses, more lorry miles. Conflicts: shareholders against local community; shareholders against suppliers. The owners gain and the old town loses: a conflict between profit and the business’s place in its community.Move the factory to a cheaper regionINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Shareholders: gainsLower rent and wages raise profit±Managers: mixedLower costs, but staff to recruit−Employees: losesMost cannot move with the jobsEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Customers: mixedLower prices, longer deliveries−Suppliers: losesLocal suppliers lose the contract−Local community: losesThe old town loses jobs and spending±Government: mixedJobs move from one region to another−Pressure groups: losesMore lorry miles+ gains, − loses, ± mixed. Dashed red arcs join the groups in conflict. Redwick Packaging is fictional.
Stakeholders and one decision: move the factory to a cheaper region. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: move the factory to a cheaper region. Shareholders: gains, lower rent and wages raise profit. Managers: mixed, lower costs, but staff to recruit. Employees: loses, most cannot move with the jobs. Customers: mixed, lower prices, longer deliveries. Suppliers: loses, local suppliers lose the contract. Local community: loses, the old town loses jobs and spending. Government: mixed, jobs move from one region to another. Pressure groups: loses, more lorry miles. Conflicts: shareholders against local community; shareholders against suppliers. The owners gain and the old town loses: a conflict between profit and the business’s place in its community.Move the factory to a cheaperregionINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS+Shareholders: gainsLower rent and wages raiseprofit±Managers: mixedLower costs, but staff torecruit−Employees: losesMost cannot move with the jobsEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Customers: mixedLower prices, longer deliveries−Suppliers: losesLocal suppliers lose thecontract−Local community: losesThe old town loses jobs andspending±Government: mixedJobs move from one region toanother−Pressure groups: losesMore lorry milesConflicts: Shareholders against localcommunity; Shareholders againstsuppliers. Dashed boxes are inconflict.

The owners gain and the old town loses: a conflict between profit and the business’s place in its community.

Switch to recycled packaging

Stakeholders and one decision: switch to recycled packaging. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: switch to recycled packaging. Shareholders: mixed, higher costs now, a better brand later. Managers: gains, a stronger brand to sell. Employees: gains, pride in the work. Customers: mixed, a greener product at a higher price. Suppliers: mixed, new suppliers win; old ones lose. Local community: gains, less waste to landfill. Government: gains, helps meet waste targets. Pressure groups: gains, a goal of their campaign met. Conflicts: shareholders against pressure groups. Most groups gain, but shareholders and customers pay more for now: a trade-off between short-term profit and corporate social responsibility.Switch to recycled packagingINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Shareholders: mixedHigher costs now, a better brand later+Managers: gainsA stronger brand to sell+Employees: gainsPride in the workEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Customers: mixedA greener product at a higher price±Suppliers: mixedNew suppliers win; old ones lose+Local community: gainsLess waste to landfill+Government: gainsHelps meet waste targets+Pressure groups: gainsA goal of their campaign met+ gains, − loses, ± mixed. Dashed red arcs join the groups in conflict. Redwick Packaging is fictional.
Stakeholders and one decision: switch to recycled packaging. Eight stakeholder groups and one decision, each marked as gaining, losing or mixed, with the main conflicts between them joined by dashed arcs.Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: switch to recycled packaging. Shareholders: mixed, higher costs now, a better brand later. Managers: gains, a stronger brand to sell. Employees: gains, pride in the work. Customers: mixed, a greener product at a higher price. Suppliers: mixed, new suppliers win; old ones lose. Local community: gains, less waste to landfill. Government: gains, helps meet waste targets. Pressure groups: gains, a goal of their campaign met. Conflicts: shareholders against pressure groups. Most groups gain, but shareholders and customers pay more for now: a trade-off between short-term profit and corporate social responsibility.Switch to recycled packagingINTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Shareholders: mixedHigher costs now, a better brandlater+Managers: gainsA stronger brand to sell+Employees: gainsPride in the workEXTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS±Customers: mixedA greener product at a higherprice±Suppliers: mixedNew suppliers win; old ones lose+Local community: gainsLess waste to landfill+Government: gainsHelps meet waste targets+Pressure groups: gainsA goal of their campaign metConflicts: Shareholders againstpressure groups. Dashed boxes are inconflict.

Most groups gain, but shareholders and customers pay more for now: a trade-off between short-term profit and corporate social responsibility.

Stakeholders and one decision Who gains and who loses from three decisions at a fictional manufacturer, and where they conflict.
Text description

Redwick Packaging, a fictional manufacturer, considers a decision: automate the packing line. Shareholders: gains, lower costs raise profit. Managers: mixed, a cheaper line, but a hard change to lead. Employees: loses, 30 packing jobs go. Customers: gains, faster, more reliable orders. Suppliers: gains, machine makers win an order. Local community: loses, fewer local jobs. Government: mixed, more tax from profit, more people out of work. Pressure groups: mixed, less waste, but job losses. Conflicts: shareholders against employees; customers against local community. Owners and customers gain from lower costs; employees and the town lose jobs. The conflict is about who bears the cost of efficiency.

Download SVG

Section 01: Where it is used