Diagram · Unit 2 · 2.3

Leadership styles compared

SL and HL Compare two side by side

Choose two styles to compare; the facts that differ are marked.

Compare two leadership styles

Autocratic

Autocratic leadership. Autocratic leadership: the leader decides alone and gives instructions.Autocratic leadership. The leader decides alone and gives instructions. Instructions go down; nothing comes back up. Who decides: The leader, alone. Staff involvement: Little: staff carry out instructions. Communication: One way, downward. Speed of decisions: Fast. Suits: A crisis, a simple or dangerous task, people new to the work. Risks: Low morale and commitment; ideas from staff go unheard.LeaderTeamThe leader decides alone and givesinstructionsInstructions go down; nothing comesback up.
Who decides
The leader, alone
Staff involvement
Little: staff carry out instructions
Communication
One way, downward
Speed of decisions
Fast
Suits
A crisis, a simple or dangerous task, people new to the work
Risks
Low morale and commitment; ideas from staff go unheard

Paternalistic

Paternalistic leadership. Paternalistic leadership: the leader decides alone, in what they see as the staff’s best interests.Paternalistic leadership. The leader decides alone, in what they see as the staff’s best interests. Instructions go down; views come up, but the leader decides. Who decides: The leader, alone, after hearing staff. Staff involvement: Consulted and cared for, but not deciding. Communication: Mostly downward, with views heard upward. Speed of decisions: Fairly fast. Suits: Staff who value security and trust the leader. Risks: Dependence on the leader; staff may feel talked down to.LeaderTeamThe leader decides alone, in what theysee as the staff’s best interestsInstructions go down; views come up,but the leader decides.
Who decides
The leader, alone, after hearing staff
Staff involvement
Consulted and cared for, but not deciding
Communication
Mostly downward, with views heard upward
Speed of decisions
Fairly fast
Suits
Staff who value security and trust the leader
Risks
Dependence on the leader; staff may feel talked down to

Democratic

Democratic leadership. Democratic leadership: the leader consults, and decisions are shaped by the people affected.Democratic leadership. The leader consults, and decisions are shaped by the people affected. Views flow both ways and across the team; the decision is shared. Who decides: The leader with the team, sometimes by a vote. Staff involvement: High: staff shape the decision. Communication: Two way, and across the team. Speed of decisions: Slower. Suits: People with knowledge to contribute, where commitment matters. Risks: Slow decisions; a split team; too slow for a crisis.LeaderTeamThe leader consults, and decisions areshaped by the people affectedViews flow both ways and across theteam; the decision is shared.
Who decides
The leader with the team, sometimes by a vote
Staff involvement
High: staff shape the decision
Communication
Two way, and across the team
Speed of decisions
Slower
Suits
People with knowledge to contribute, where commitment matters
Risks
Slow decisions; a split team; too slow for a crisis

Laissez-faire

Laissez-faire leadership. Laissez-faire leadership: the leader sets the goal and few rules, and the team decides how.Laissez-faire leadership. The leader sets the goal and few rules, and the team decides how. The leader sets the goal; the team decides how to reach it. Who decides: The team. Staff involvement: Very high: staff organize themselves. Communication: Mostly within the team. Speed of decisions: Depends on the team. Suits: An expert, motivated team that works best with autonomy. Risks: Drift, unclear roles and missed deadlines if the team is not ready.LeaderTeamthe goalThe leader sets the goal and fewrules, and the team decides howThe leader sets the goal; the teamdecides how to reach it.
Who decides
The team
Staff involvement
Very high: staff organize themselves
Communication
Mostly within the team
Speed of decisions
Depends on the team
Suits
An expert, motivated team that works best with autonomy
Risks
Drift, unclear roles and missed deadlines if the team is not ready

Situational

Situational leadership. Situational leadership: the leader adapts the style to the task and to the team’s readiness.Situational leadership. The leader adapts the style to the task and to the team’s readiness. Directing in a crisis, coaching a new team, delegating to experts. Who decides: It varies: the style follows the situation. Staff involvement: Grows as the team grows more capable. Communication: Matched to the style in use. Speed of decisions: Fast when it must be, slower when it can be. Suits: Teams and tasks that differ, as two shifts or two projects do. Risks: Can look inconsistent; needs a leader who reads situations well.LeaderTeamLeader decidesTeam decidesCrisisNew teamExpertsThe leader adapts the style to thetask and to the team’s readinessDirecting in a crisis, coaching a newteam, delegating to experts.
Who decides
It varies: the style follows the situation
Staff involvement
Grows as the team grows more capable
Communication
Matched to the style in use
Speed of decisions
Fast when it must be, slower when it can be
Suits
Teams and tasks that differ, as two shifts or two projects do
Risks
Can look inconsistent; needs a leader who reads situations well

Leadership styles compared Who decides, and which way communication runs, in each of the five styles: choose two to set side by side.
Text description

The five leadership styles in the guide, each drawn as a leader and a team with the direction of communication. Autocratic: the leader decides alone and gives instructions. Who decides: the leader, alone; Staff involvement: little: staff carry out instructions; Communication: one way, downward; Speed of decisions: fast; Suits: a crisis, a simple or dangerous task, people new to the work; Risks: low morale and commitment; ideas from staff go unheard. Paternalistic: the leader decides alone, in what they see as the staff’s best interests. Who decides: the leader, alone, after hearing staff; Staff involvement: consulted and cared for, but not deciding; Communication: mostly downward, with views heard upward; Speed of decisions: fairly fast; Suits: staff who value security and trust the leader; Risks: dependence on the leader; staff may feel talked down to. Democratic: the leader consults, and decisions are shaped by the people affected. Who decides: the leader with the team, sometimes by a vote; Staff involvement: high: staff shape the decision; Communication: two way, and across the team; Speed of decisions: slower; Suits: people with knowledge to contribute, where commitment matters; Risks: slow decisions; a split team; too slow for a crisis. Laissez-faire: the leader sets the goal and few rules, and the team decides how. Who decides: the team; Staff involvement: very high: staff organize themselves; Communication: mostly within the team; Speed of decisions: depends on the team; Suits: an expert, motivated team that works best with autonomy; Risks: drift, unclear roles and missed deadlines if the team is not ready. Situational: the leader adapts the style to the task and to the team’s readiness. Who decides: it varies: the style follows the situation; Staff involvement: grows as the team grows more capable; Communication: matched to the style in use; Speed of decisions: fast when it must be, slower when it can be; Suits: teams and tasks that differ, as two shifts or two projects do; Risks: can look inconsistent; needs a leader who reads situations well.

Download SVG

Section 01: Where it is used