Strategy Studio · Stage 2 of 4: Generate options

Scenario planner

Sort the forces behind a decision by impact and uncertainty, build four futures on the two critical uncertainties, each with a narrative, implications and early-warning signposts, and test your options in all four.

Section 01: Build your analysis

The tool opens on a worked example. Change anything: the analysis follows, and your work is kept on this device.

Scripts are off, so this is the worked example as a finished analysis. Every part of it can be read; to build your own, turn scripts on.

Your work is kept on this device as you type.

Your inputs

The decision the scenarios are for.

How far ahead, such as a year.

Driving forces

The forces outside the business that will shape the answer, from a STEEPLE scan or your own. Rate each for its impact on the question and how uncertain its outcome is; give both ends of its range.

  1. Class Critical uncertainty (A candidate for an axis: important, and genuinely open.)

  2. Class Critical uncertainty (A candidate for an axis: important, and genuinely open.)

  3. Class Predetermined element (Important but more predictable: build it into every scenario.)

  4. Class Background (Less important and more predictable: note it and move on.)

  5. Class Secondary uncertainty (Uncertain but less important: watch it, and use it to colour the stories.)

  6. Class Secondary uncertainty (Uncertain but less important: watch it, and use it to colour the stories.)

The two axes

Choose two critical uncertainties that can vary independently. Their ends make the four futures.

Future 1

Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year

A short, memorable name for this world.

How the world gets there from today, and what it is like to do business in it.

Things you could observe early that would show this future arriving.

Future 2

Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter

A short, memorable name for this world.

How the world gets there from today, and what it is like to do business in it.

Things you could observe early that would show this future arriving.

Future 3

Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year

A short, memorable name for this world.

How the world gets there from today, and what it is like to do business in it.

Things you could observe early that would show this future arriving.

Future 4

Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter

A short, memorable name for this world.

How the world gets there from today, and what it is like to do business in it.

Things you could observe early that would show this future arriving.

Your options, tested in each future

For each option, judge how well it would do in each future, from 1 (fails) to 5 (thrives).

The analysis

Worked example Northvale Cycles is fictional and its figures are simulated. Change anything and this becomes your own analysis.

The driving forces

Northvale Cycles. Focal question: Which route to growth should Northvale Cycles commit to, if it must still pay off whatever happens by 2030? Horizon: 2030.

Each driving force with its impact, its uncertainty and the class they give it
No.Driving forceImpactUncertaintyClass
1How far cities restrict vansPolitical; axis A: Three nearby cities will charge vans to enter their low-emission zones from 2027; whether others follow, and how strictly, is open.54Critical uncertainty
2The price of motors and batteriesEconomic; axis B: Motor and battery prices rose 9% in a year, while suppliers expect the battery cost of each kilometre of range to fall by about a quarter over three years.44Critical uncertainty
3Growth in city deliveriesSocial: Parcel deliveries in the region's cities have risen every year for a decade, and the delivery firms plan for more.42Predetermined element
6A national grant for business cargo bikesPolitical: The national government is consulting; no decision is due before next year.35Secondary uncertainty
5Direct-online brands entering fleet salesEconomic: The two largest online brands deliver fitted bikes to the door within five days; neither sells to fleets yet.34Secondary uncertainty
4Stricter battery safety and recycling rulesLegal: From 2027 every e-bike battery model must pass new tests, and makers must pay towards recycling.31Background
  • Critical uncertainty impact 4 or 5, uncertainty 4 or 5
  • Predetermined element impact 4 or 5, uncertainty 3 or less
  • Secondary uncertainty impact 3 or less, uncertainty 4 or 5
  • Background impact 3 or less, uncertainty 3 or less
  • High means 4 or 5: the platform's teaching convention.

Four futures

Four futures on two critical uncertaintiesScenario matrix on two critical uncertainties: How far cities restrict vans (from Van charges stay in the three cities already planned to Van-free centres spread to most large cities) and The price of motors and batteries (from Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year to Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter). Slow lane: Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year; option 1 2 of 5, option 2 3 of 5, option 3 3 of 5, option 4 2 of 5. Price war: Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter; option 1 3 of 5, option 2 3 of 5, option 3 3 of 5, option 4 2 of 5. Squeezed boom: Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year; option 1 4 of 5, option 2 4 of 5, option 3 3 of 5, option 4 2 of 5. Cargo boom: Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter; option 1 5 of 5, option 2 4 of 5, option 3 3 of 5, option 4 3 of 5.Price warOption 1Holds upOption 2Holds upOption 3Holds upOption 4StrugglesCargo boomOption 1ThrivesOption 2Does wellOption 3Holds upOption 4Holds upSlow laneOption 1StrugglesOption 2Holds upOption 3Holds upOption 4StrugglesSqueezed boomOption 1Does wellOption 2Does wellOption 3Holds upOption 4StrugglesHow far citiesrestrict vansVan charges stayin the threecities alreadyplannedHow far citiesrestrict vansVan-free centresspread to mostlarge citiesThe price of motors and batteries:Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enterThe price of motors and batteries:Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year
  • Each future is one combination of the ends of the two axes
  • Dots: how each option does there, from 1 (fails) to 5 (thrives), numbered as in the inputs
  • Green: does well (4 or 5); red: struggles (2 or less); also in the table below

Four futures built on how far cities restrict vans and the price of motors and batteries, to 2030. Every one of them includes growth in city deliveries. "Fleet bikes, staged: a paid trial first and a second motor supplier" and "City bikes for dealers abroad" hold up in all four. "Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms, all in" is a bet on "Squeezed boom" and "Cargo boom": prepare it, and watch the signposts. "Relaunch commuter e-bikes online" struggles somewhere and does well nowhere. Scenarios are not forecasts: none of the four is the likeliest, and the real future may mix them. Their value is in plans that hold up across them, and in the signposts that show which way the world is moving.

Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year

Slow lane

Only the three cities already planning van charges introduce them, and the others wait to see the effect. Motor and battery prices keep climbing as demand for batteries elsewhere outstrips supply. Delivery firms run their vans for longer and buy cargo bikes only for routes inside the charging zones, and cargo bike makers compete for a small fleet market while their costs rise.

For the business: Fleet sales stay small and margins thin. Northvale should not build capacity ahead of orders: keep the fleet offer to the three cities, protect the margin with service contracts, and lean on family cargo bikes and the dealers.

Signposts:

  • No further city announces van charges by the end of 2027
  • Motor and battery prices rise again at the next price round
  • Delivery firms extend their van leases instead of ordering bikes

Van charges stay in the three cities already planned; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter

Price war

Van rules stay as planned, but battery prices fall quickly. E-bikes become cheaper for everyone, and the direct-online brands use the savings to cut their prices further. Fleet demand grows slowly, mainly where the van charges apply, and delivery firms ask for lower prices rather than longer service.

For the business: Northvale cannot win on price against the online brands. Its edge is service: fleet contracts that bundle maintenance, and dealers who repair. Falling costs ease the margin, but only if prices are held.

Signposts:

  • Battery prices fall at two price rounds in a row
  • An online brand launches a cargo model below Northvale's price
  • Fleet tenders ask for price cuts rather than service terms

Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices keep rising, as they did by 9% last year

Squeezed boom

More large cities announce van-free centres, and delivery firms rush to replace their vans. Demand for cargo bikes soars, but motors and batteries are scarce and dear, lead times stretch and makers ration their supply. Whoever has secured components wins the contracts.

For the business: The fleet strategy is right, but supply is the constraint. A second motor supplier, contracts that pass on component price rises and a clear rule for which customers are served first matter more than marketing.

Signposts:

  • Two more large cities announce van-free centres
  • Motor lead times pass 20 weeks again
  • Fleet buyers accept price-adjustment clauses

Van-free centres spread to most large cities; Prices fall as battery costs drop and new suppliers enter

Cargo boom

Van-free centres spread and component prices fall. Fleet demand grows fast and margins are healthy, which draws in rivals: van makers launch cargo bikes and online brands start selling to fleets. The early leaders lock in fleets with service contracts lasting several years.

For the business: The best case for the fleet plan, and a race. Northvale should add the second shift early, sign multi-year service contracts with the first fleets, and use its dealers as a servicing network rivals cannot match quickly.

Signposts:

  • A van maker announces a cargo bike
  • Two more large cities announce van-free centres
  • Battery prices fall at successive price rounds

Your options in each future

Each option rated from 1 (fails) to 5 (thrives) in each future, with its worst rating, its average and the verdict
OptionSlow lanePrice warSqueezed boomCargo boomWorstAverageVerdict
Fleet bikes, staged: a paid trial first and a second motor supplier3Holds up3Holds up4Does well4Does well33.50Robusta candidate to commit to now
City bikes for dealers abroad3Holds up3Holds up3Holds up3Holds up33.00Robusta candidate to commit to now
Fleet cargo bikes for delivery firms, all in2Struggles3Holds up4Does well5Thrives23.50Contingenta bet on some futures: prepare it, and commit when its signposts appear
Relaunch commuter e-bikes online2Struggles2Struggles2Struggles3Holds up22.25Fragiledrop it or redesign it
  • Robust holds up (3 or more) in every future
  • Contingent does well (4 or 5) in some futures and struggles (2 or less) in others
  • Fragile struggles in some futures and does well in none

A robust option is not the best in any one future; it is the one you would not regret in any of them. A contingent option can still be right, if you commit when its signposts appear.

Checks

No problems found: the question and horizon are set, the axes are two different critical uncertainties with both ends named, and every future has a name, a narrative, implications and signposts.

Section 02: About this tool

What it is for, how to use it, what it cannot do, and where it stands in the IB course.

Purpose

To prepare a long-lived decision for a future that cannot be forecast, by finding the few uncertainties that would change the answer, picturing the futures they could produce, and choosing options that hold up in all of them, or knowing which signposts would justify a bet on one.

IB syllabus status

Enrichment Not in the guide

Scenario planning is not in the guide and is not one of its toolkit tools, so this tool is enrichment. It builds on STEEPLE analysis, a toolkit tool for SL and HL (Business management guide, p. 14), serves the strategic objectives of 1.3 (p. 23), and connects to contingency planning in 5.7, which is HL only (p. 35). The method follows the scenario planning of Peter Schwartz (1991) and Kees van der Heijden (1996).

Serves 1.3 Business objectives , 5.7 Crisis management and contingency planning

How to use it

  1. State the focal question and the horizon. Scenarios are built for a decision, not for the world in general.
  2. List the driving forces, from a STEEPLE scan or your own, and rate each for its impact on the question and for how uncertain its outcome is. Give both ends of each one's range.
  3. Read the classes: forces that are important and fairly predictable are predetermined elements, part of every future; those that are important and genuinely open are the critical uncertainties.
  4. Choose two critical uncertainties that can vary independently as the axes. Their ends make the four futures.
  5. Name each future, write how the world gets there and what doing business in it is like, what it would mean for the business, and two or more signposts that would show it arriving.
  6. Rate each option in every future. Commit to options that hold up in all four; keep contingent ones ready, with the signposts that would trigger them.

Limitations

  • Four futures drawn on two axes leave out every other combination. The forces not chosen still matter, and the real future may mix the scenarios.
  • The ratings are judgements, and an option's verdict depends on how generous they are. The comparison matters more than the numbers.
  • Scenarios are not forecasts and carry no probabilities, so they cannot say which future is likeliest. Where probabilities can honestly be estimated, a decision tree does that job.
  • Good scenarios take research and discussion. A set written alone in an hour mostly shows what its author already believed.

A model is an aid to judgement, not a universal answer. Use what it shows, then decide, and say why.

Section 03: Using what it shows

Recommended use

The recommended use is to let the futures change the plan, not just describe them. For Northvale, going all in on fleets does well only where van-free centres spread; the staged plan, a paid trial first and a second motor supplier, holds up in every future, and the signposts say when to scale it up. That is the plan the memo recommends, now with its conditions in view: a strong answer names the robust option, the bets it keeps ready, and the signposts that would trigger them.

Read alongside