Revision sheet · Unit 1: Introduction to business management
1.4 Stakeholders
Key points
- A stakeholder is anyone affected by a business or able to affect it; a shareholder owns part of a company and is only one stakeholder group.
- Internal stakeholders, the employees, managers and owners, belong to the organization; external stakeholders, such as customers, suppliers, lenders, government, the local community, pressure groups and competitors, are outside it but affected by it or able to influence it.
- Each group has its own objectives, so a decision is better for some stakeholders and worse for others, never simply good or bad for the business.
- Stakeholders respond by leaving, buying elsewhere, striking, lending on harder terms, campaigning or regulating; their power depends on how much the business needs them, how organized they are and what alternatives they have.
- Conflict arises because objectives differ and resources are limited, but over the long term many objectives overlap, and strong answers show both.
- Stakeholder mapping plots power against interest to decide whom to manage closely, keep satisfied, keep informed or monitor. The guide does not name it, and power is not the same as a fair claim.
- Businesses manage conflict by consulting, compromising and prioritizing; the stakeholder concept treats every group as a partner, while other businesses put shareholders first within the law.
- The guide sets 1.4 at AO2, so analyse the two or three groups most affected with the case's evidence rather than listing every group; evaluation questions combine stakeholders with objectives and CSR (1.3) or growth (1.5).
- The kind of organization shapes its stakeholders. Owners manage sole traders; ownership and control divide in public companies; members are owners and customers, workers or suppliers in cooperatives; and beneficiaries, donors and volunteers join social enterprises and NGOs.
- Over the long run many objectives overlap. The shareholder view puts the owners first within the law; the stakeholder view, or stakeholder concept, treats every group's claim as legitimate and balances them.
- To analyse a decision, name it, choose the two or three groups most affected, trace the effect on each with the case's figures, judge their power to respond, look for conflict and common ground, and weigh what matters most.
Common examination mistakes
-
Defining a shareholder instead, or treating the two words as the same, is a common error.
-
“Stakeholders and shareholders mean the same thing.”
Instead: Shareholders own the company and are one group of stakeholders; stakeholders include many groups that own nothing.
-
“Shareholders run the company day to day.”
Instead: In most companies the directors and managers run it; shareholders elect the directors and vote on major decisions.
-
“All internal stakeholders want the same things.”
Instead: Employees, managers and owners often disagree over pay, profit, risk and control.
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 1.4, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Cooperative
- A business owned and controlled by its members, who may be its customers, its workers or the producers who supply it; they share the benefits it creates and run it democratically, normally on the basis of one member, one vote.
- Corporate social responsibility (CSR)
- A business's acceptance that it is responsible for the effects of its activities on society and the environment, and its commitment to act in the interests of stakeholders beyond what the law requires.
- Divorce of ownership and control
- The situation in a large company where the shareholders own the business but professional directors and managers decide how it is run.
- External stakeholder
- A stakeholder outside the organization that is affected by its activities or can influence them, such as customers, suppliers, lenders, the government, the local community and pressure groups.
- Internal stakeholder
- A stakeholder that is part of the organization: its employees, its managers and directors, and its owners.
- Pressure group
- An organized group that tries to influence the decisions of businesses or governments on a particular issue, without seeking political office itself.
- Shareholder
- An owner of a company, holding one or more of the shares into which its ownership is divided.
- Shareholder value
- The value a company creates for its owners, mainly through a rising share price and the dividends it pays.
- Stakeholder
- Any individual or group with an interest in what an organization does, because its decisions have an impact on them or because they can influence those decisions.
- Stakeholder concept
- The view that a business should take account of the interests of all its stakeholders when making decisions, not only those of its owners.
- Stakeholder conflict
- A situation in which the interests or objectives of different stakeholder groups clash, so a decision that benefits one group harms or disappoints another.
- Stakeholder mapping
- A way of prioritizing stakeholders by plotting each group on a grid according to its power over the organization and its interest in a particular decision.
- Triple bottom line
- A way of judging an organization's performance by three measures rather than by profit alone: its social impact (people), its environmental impact (planet) and its financial results (profit).
Frameworks and tools
From the frameworks library: what each is for, a situation it suits, and one limitation.
-
Mendelow's matrix Enrichment
- Purpose
- To prioritize stakeholders before a decision and plan how to engage each group, so that the business neither ignores a powerful group nor spends equal effort on everyone.
- Use it when
- Planning how to engage stakeholders before a decision that some will oppose, such as a new warehouse near a village.
- One limitation
- Power and interest are judgements, often made by managers with their own interests.
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Brackenholt Stone wants to extend its quarry by 40 hectares. The extension would create 25 jobs, but it would send more lorries through a nearby village and remove woodland that local people walk in.
Analyse the conflict between two of Brackenholt Stone's stakeholder groups over the extension.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Chooses two groups whose objectives clash, such as shareholders and employees, who gain profit and jobs, against villagers and walkers, who lose quiet, safety and woodland.
- Uses the case's evidence for what each group wants and why.
- Analyses each group's power and interest: the council's planning decision gives it great power, and villagers can gain power by organizing and campaigning.
- Notes where interests overlap, such as villagers who would welcome the new jobs.
- Brackenholt Stone's managers expect strong opposition from the village to the quarry extension.
Suggest two ways Brackenholt Stone could reduce the villagers' opposition.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Consult early and openly, so villagers' concerns shape the plan rather than meeting a decision already made.
- Limit the harm, for example by restricting lorry hours or routing lorries away from the village.
- Offer something back, such as a community fund or a promise to restore the land as a nature reserve after quarrying.
- Explains why each would lower opposition, and what it would cost the business.
- Tallowmere Dairy, a dairy owned by its farmer members, plans to replace deliveries by its own drivers with an outside courier firm.
Distinguish between internal and external stakeholders, using examples from Tallowmere Dairy.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Defines internal stakeholders as those within the organization, such as Tallowmere's drivers and its farmer members, who own it.
- Defines external stakeholders as those outside it but affected by it, such as the courier firm, the shops it supplies and the drivers' families.
- Shows why the difference matters here: the drivers lose their jobs from inside, while the courier gains a contract from outside.
Answer from memory
10 recall questions from the 1.4 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
What is the difference between a stakeholder and a shareholder?
A stakeholder is anyone affected by, or able to affect, a business. A shareholder owns part of a company through its shares, and is only one stakeholder group.
How well did you recall it? -
Name three internal and three external stakeholder groups.
Internal: employees, managers and directors, owners and shareholders. External: for example customers, suppliers, lenders, government, the local community, pressure groups and competitors.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two reasons why stakeholders' objectives conflict.
Their objectives differ (profit, pay, prices, a quiet neighbourhood), and the business has limited resources to share between them, so a gain for one group is often a cost for another.
How well did you recall it? -
What two things does stakeholder mapping compare, and which group must be managed closely?
Each group's power over the business and its interest in the decision. Groups with high power and high interest, the key players, must be managed closely.
How well did you recall it? -
Give one limitation of stakeholder mapping.
For example, placing a group is a judgement; power and interest change over time; weak groups can join together and become powerful.
How well did you recall it? -
How can a business reduce conflict between stakeholders?
For example by consulting and communicating early, compromising or phasing changes, and prioritizing groups by their power, interest and the business's objectives.
How well did you recall it? -
Why is the conflict between owners and managers usually absent in a sole trader?
The owner usually manages the business, so ownership and control are in the same hands; in a public company they are divided between shareholders and directors.
How well did you recall it? -
What is unusual about the stakeholders of a cooperative?
Its members are its owners and also its customers, workers or suppliers, so they hold two stakeholder roles at once, and they decide by voting, usually one member, one vote.
How well did you recall it? -
Distinguish between the shareholder view and the stakeholder view of a business.
The shareholder view puts the owners' returns first, meeting other groups' needs as far as the law requires and as far as it pays; the stakeholder view treats every group's claim as legitimate and balances them.
How well did you recall it? -
A pay rise costs $30,000 a year and replacing a worker who leaves costs $4,000. How many fewer workers must leave for the rise to pay for itself?
$30,000 ÷ $4,000 = 7.5, so at least 8 fewer leavers.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.