Framework comparison
Internal against external sources of finance
Should the business pay for this from its own resources, or raise money from outside?
Internal finance comes from within the business and costs no interest or ownership; external finance brings in more money, at a price in interest, control or both.
Standing in the IB course
Internal sources of finance
IB syllabus 3.2 Sources of finance: Internal sources of finance: personal funds (for sole traders), retained profit and the sale of assets (AO2); Business management guide, p. 28.
Key terms: Internal sources of finance, Personal funds, Retained profit, Sale of assets
External sources of finance
IB syllabus 3.2 Sources of finance: External sources of finance: share capital, loan capital, overdrafts, trade credit, crowdfunding, leasing, microfinance providers and business angels (AO2); Business management guide, p. 28.
Key terms: External sources of finance, Share capital, Loan capital, Overdraft, Crowdfunding, Leasing, Business angel
Purpose
Internal sources of finance
To fund spending from money the business, or its owner, already has, without borrowing or selling a share.
External sources of finance
To raise money from outside the business when its own resources are not enough, or when keeping them is wiser.
Structure
Internal sources of finance
The guide names three: personal funds (for sole traders), retained profit, and the sale of assets.
External sources of finance
The guide names share capital, loan capital, overdrafts, trade credit, crowdfunding, leasing, microfinance providers and business angels; some are short term, others long term.
The context it suits
Internal sources of finance
A business with profits kept back or assets it no longer needs, funding a modest investment, or a sole trader starting small with savings.
External sources of finance
Larger investments, start-ups with little of their own money, rapid growth, or a temporary cash shortfall, matched to how long the money is needed.
Strengths
Internal sources of finance
- No interest to pay and nothing to repay.
- No loss of ownership or control to outsiders.
- Quick to arrange: no lender or investor to persuade.
External sources of finance
- Can raise far more than the business could find internally.
- Lets the business keep its own reserves as a cushion.
- Some sources bring more than money, such as a business angel's advice.
Limitations
Internal sources of finance
- Limited to what the business already has, which may not be enough for a large investment.
- Retained profit used here cannot be paid to owners or kept as a cushion.
- Selling assets may weaken the business, and a quick sale may fetch a low price.
External sources of finance
- Loans and overdrafts carry interest and must be repaid, whatever happens to sales.
- Share capital and business angels dilute ownership and control.
- Lenders may want security and a trading record that a new business lacks.
Common mistakes
Internal sources of finance
- Treating retained profit as free: it has an opportunity cost, the return it could earn elsewhere.
- Confusing retained profit with cash: profit kept in the business may already be tied up in stock or equipment.
- Recommending the sale of assets the business still needs to operate.
External sources of finance
- Using short-term finance, such as an overdraft, for a long-term asset.
- Treating share capital as free because it carries no interest: owners expect a return.
- Listing every source rather than choosing the one that fits the business's situation.
A business application
Internal sources of finance
Fictional Meadowgate Print
A printer replaces two older machines with one faster one. It funds the new machine from retained profit and the sale of the old machines, paying no interest; the cash cushion falls for a year, which the owners accept.
External sources of finance
Fictional Meadowgate Print
Two years later the printer wants a second site, costing far more than its reserves. It takes a five-year loan secured on its building, keeping full ownership; a slow first year would still have to meet the repayments, so the bank asks for a cash flow forecast.
In an examination answer
Internal sources of finance
Recommended strategy
Name the source precisely and apply it to the business's situation: has it enough profit or spare assets for this need? Weigh cost, control and how quickly the money is available, and link the choice to the size and the term of the need, which the guide asks you to judge.
External sources of finance
Recommended strategy
Match the source to the need: its size, how long the money is needed, the security the business can offer and how much control the owners will give up. Recommend one source and justify it against an alternative, using figures from the case where there are any.
Section 01: The difference, in a paragraph
The difference is where the money comes from, and so what it costs. Internal finance comes from within: it is cheap and keeps control, but is limited. External finance comes from outside: it can be large, but it costs interest, a share of ownership, or both, and may need security.
Section 02: Which to use when
-
A modest investment, and the business has retained profit or assets it no longer needs.
Use Internal sources of finance
Internal finance avoids interest and keeps control, and the business can afford it.
-
A large investment, such as a new site, far beyond the business's reserves.
Use External sources of finance
Only external finance can raise enough; the choice is then between debt and equity.
-
A start-up whose owner's savings cover only part of the costs.
Use External sources of finance
Personal funds start the business, and an external source closes the gap.
Section 03: Using them together
Most investments use both: a business puts in some of its own money, which reassures a lender, and borrows the rest. Use the Finance Desk's cash flow lab to see how a way of paying changes the cash position month by month.
Section 04: Read more
In the course
Statements about the course come from the curriculum file, checked against the Business management guide (first assessment 2024); exam advice is the platform's own, labelled Recommended strategy; every business in the applications is fictional. Compare any two frameworks in the library.
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief, https://the-business-brief-dun.vercel.app/frameworks/compare/internal-vs-external-sources-of-finance/. Original teaching material, not an IB publication. The organizations in the teaching cases are fictional unless a case says otherwise.