Diagram · Unit 3 · 3.8

Two projects, three methods

SL and HL Fictional figures Change the figures

Change either project’s cost or yearly returns, or the discount rate; the chart and the table follow.

Project A: a delivery van
000
000
000
000
000
000
Project B: an online shop
000
000
000
000
000
000
Net present value (HL)

Two projects, three methods. Two lines of cumulative net cash flow over five years for two fictional projects, each crossing zero at its payback point.Two fictional projects. A, a delivery van, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (50), (10), 10, 20, 30; it pays back in 2 years and 6 months. B, an online shop, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (80), (50), (10), 40, 100; it pays back in 3 years and 2.4 months. Each line crosses zero where the project has repaid its cost.(100)(50)050100012345YearCumulative net cash flow, $000ABA pays back in 2 years and 6 months. B pays back in 3 years and 2.4 months.Fictional figures.
Two projects, three methods. Two lines of cumulative net cash flow over five years for two fictional projects, each crossing zero at its payback point.Two fictional projects. A, a delivery van, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (50), (10), 10, 20, 30; it pays back in 2 years and 6 months. B, an online shop, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (80), (50), (10), 40, 100; it pays back in 3 years and 2.4 months. Each line crosses zero where the project has repaid its cost.(100)(50)050100012345YearCumulative net cash flow, $000ABA pays back in 2 years and 6 months; Bpays back in 3 years and 2.4 months.
The three methods for each project (NPV at 10%, with the guide's discount factors; NPV is HL only)
MethodProject AProject BPrefers
Payback period2 years and 6 months3 years and 2.4 monthsA
Average rate of return6.00%20.00%B
NPV at 10% (HL)$6.58k$44.43kB

The methods disagree. Payback prefers A; the ARR and NPV prefer B. Payback rewards getting the money back soon; the ARR and NPV count every year's return, and NPV also counts when it arrives. The choice depends on what the business needs most: cash back quickly, or the larger return.

The figures above are the example’s. With JavaScript on, they can be changed here.

Two projects, three methods Payback, the average rate of return and NPV (HL) can rank the same two projects differently: change the figures and see when they agree.
Text description

Two fictional projects. A, a delivery van, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (50), (10), 10, 20, 30; it pays back in 2 years and 6 months. B, an online shop, costs $100k and its cumulative net cash flow runs (100), (80), (50), (10), 40, 100; it pays back in 3 years and 2.4 months. Each line crosses zero where the project has repaid its cost.

Download SVG

Section 01: Where it is used