Revision sheet · Unit 2: Human resource management
2.7 Industrial/employee relations
HL This subtopic is HL only. If you are taking SL, it is extension material.
Key points
- Industrial or employee relations is the relationship between managers and employees, and their representatives such as trade unions, including how pay and conditions are agreed and disputes handled.
- Conflict arises because interests overlap without being the same. The commonest sources are pay, hours and conditions, job security, change, and how people are treated.
- Three lenses on conflict: unitarist (shared goals, conflict is abnormal), pluralist (different legitimate interests, manage through bargaining) and critical (unequal power, conflict never fully resolved).
- Employees' approaches: collective bargaining, work-to-rule and strike action, in rising order of pressure and of cost to themselves.
- Employers' approaches: collective bargaining, threats of redundancies, changes of contract, closure and lockouts.
- Conciliation helps the two sides reach their own agreement; arbitration has a third party decide, usually bindingly; pendulum arbitration picks one final offer in full.
- Employee participation gives staff a voice in decisions; industrial democracy gives them real power, such as seats on the board or ownership.
- A no-strike agreement swaps the right to strike for benefits and arbitration; a single-union agreement has the employer negotiate with one union only.
- Which approach works depends on bargaining power, and a win by force can cost more over time than a settlement both sides accept.
Common examination mistakes
-
Confusing conciliation with arbitration.
Instead: A conciliator helps the two sides reach their own agreement; an arbitrator decides for them, usually bindingly.
Recommended strategy
-
Assuming the side with the fairer case will win the dispute.
Instead: Outcomes depend on bargaining power: how long each side can afford the conflict, how scarce the skills are, demand for the product, and public and political support.
Recommended strategy
-
Recommending industrial action without weighing its cost to the employees themselves.
Instead: Set lost pay, the risk to jobs and the effect on future relations against the pressure the action puts on the employer.
Recommended strategy
Key definitions
The IB glossary terms of 2.7, in the platform's own words. Terms beyond the course are not included.
- Arbitration
- A way of resolving a dispute in which an independent third party hears both sides and then decides the outcome, which the two sides may agree in advance to accept as binding.
- Changes of contract
- An employer altering employees' terms and conditions, such as hours, pay, duties, shift patterns or place of work, or threatening to, as a way of cutting costs or putting pressure on employees in a dispute.
- Closure (of a workplace)
- An employer shutting a factory, office or the whole business, or threatening to do so, during a dispute or when costs become too high, so that employees face losing their jobs.
- Collective bargaining
- Negotiation between an employer, or a group of employers, and representatives of employees, usually a trade union, to agree pay and working conditions for a whole group of workers.
- Conciliation
- A way of resolving a dispute in which an independent third party helps the two sides talk and find their own agreement, without deciding the outcome for them.
- Employee participation
- Involving employees in decisions that affect their work, through methods such as consultation, works councils, quality circles, suggestion schemes and team briefings.
- Industrial action
- Action taken by employees, usually organized by a trade union, to put pressure on their employer during a dispute, such as a work-to-rule, an overtime ban, a go-slow or a strike.
- Industrial democracy
- Giving employees a real share of power over an organization's decisions, for example through elected worker representatives on the board of directors or through employee ownership.
- Industrial relations
- The relationship between an organization's management and its employees and their representatives, such as trade unions, including how pay and conditions are agreed and how disputes are handled.
- Lockout
- An employer preventing employees from entering the workplace, and so from working and being paid, until they accept the employer's terms in a dispute.
- No-strike agreement
- An agreement in which a trade union promises not to call strikes, usually in return for benefits such as better pay or conditions, or an agreed procedure, such as arbitration, for settling disputes.
- Redundancy
- Dismissal because an employee's job is no longer needed, for example after falling demand, automation, relocation or restructuring, rather than because of anything the employee has done.
- Single-union agreement
- An agreement in which an employer recognizes and negotiates with only one trade union, which represents all of the employees or all of a particular group.
- Strike action
- Industrial action in which employees collectively stop working, for a set period or until further notice, to put pressure on their employer.
- Trade union
- An organization of employees that represents its members' interests, such as pay, working conditions and job security, in dealings with employers.
- Work-to-rule
- Industrial action in which employees follow every rule and procedure exactly and do nothing beyond what their contracts require, such as overtime or tasks that rely on goodwill.
Apply it
Short exercises on fictional businesses, written for the platform; none is an IB question. Answer first, then open the outline of what a strong answer does.
- Dockworkers at Saltmarsh Port, most of them union members, have rejected a 2% pay offer while prices are rising by 6% a year. Their union is considering industrial action.
Discuss whether the union should choose a work-to-rule rather than strike action.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- A work-to-rule slows the port while members keep their pay, carries less risk to jobs and may keep public sympathy, but puts less pressure on the employer.
- Strike action puts the most pressure on the port, but members lose pay, the employer may respond with a lockout or threats of redundancy, and shipping lines may move to other ports.
- Weighs the union's bargaining power: the dockworkers' skills, the port's need to keep ships moving, and public opinion.
- Reaches a judgement, for example to start with a work-to-rule and keep a strike in reserve.
- After four weeks of action, Saltmarsh Port's managers and the union agree to bring in an independent third party.
Distinguish between conciliation and arbitration as ways to end the dispute at Saltmarsh Port.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Conciliation: an independent person helps both sides talk and reach their own agreement; nothing is imposed.
- Arbitration: an independent person hears both sides and decides, usually bindingly; pendulum arbitration chooses one side's final offer in full.
- Shows which suits when: conciliation while the sides can still agree, arbitration when they need a decision made for them.
- Saltmarsh Port's managers must respond to the union's work-to-rule, which has cut the number of ships handled by a third.
Explain two approaches the port's managers could take in response to the industrial action.
Show a model answer outlineModel answer outline
- Collective bargaining: return to negotiations with an improved offer, perhaps linking pay to productivity.
- Pressure such as threats of redundancies, changes of contract or a lockout.
- Explains the likely effect of each, including the risk that pressure hardens the dispute and damages relations for years.
Answer from memory
12 recall questions from the 2.7 notes
Answer each question from memory, out loud or on paper, before you reveal the answer. Your ratings also schedule these questions in your flashcards.
-
What is meant by industrial or employee relations?
The relationship between an organization's managers and its employees, and their representatives such as trade unions, including how pay and conditions are agreed and how disputes are handled.
How well did you recall it? -
Give four sources of conflict in the workplace.
For example pay and benefits, hours and working conditions, job security, change such as new technology or restructuring, and how people are treated by managers.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between the unitarist and the pluralist view of conflict?
The unitarist view sees the organization as a team with shared goals, so conflict is abnormal and unions unnecessary. The pluralist view sees groups with different, legitimate interests, so conflict is normal and is managed through negotiation with unions.
How well did you recall it? -
Name the three approaches to conflict the guide lists for employees.
Collective bargaining, work-to-rule and strike action.
How well did you recall it? -
Name the five approaches to conflict the guide lists for employers.
Collective bargaining, threats of redundancies, changes of contract, closure and lockouts.
How well did you recall it? -
Why do employees usually keep their pay during a work-to-rule but not during a strike?
In a work-to-rule they are still doing what their contracts require, just nothing more; in a strike they stop working altogether.
How well did you recall it? -
What is a lockout?
An employer preventing employees from entering the workplace, so that they cannot work or be paid, until they accept its terms; the employer's counterpart to a strike.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the key difference between conciliation and arbitration?
A conciliator helps the two sides reach their own agreement and decides nothing; an arbitrator hears both sides and decides the outcome, usually bindingly.
How well did you recall it? -
How does pendulum arbitration encourage reasonable offers?
The arbitrator must choose one side's final offer in full, so each side has an incentive to make the offer that looks more reasonable.
How well did you recall it? -
What is the difference between employee participation and industrial democracy?
Participation involves employees in decisions through consultation, works councils or quality circles; industrial democracy gives them a real share of power, such as elected representatives on the board or ownership of the business.
How well did you recall it? -
What does each side gain and give up in a no-strike agreement?
The union gives up the right to strike for a period; in return employees usually gain better pay or conditions and an agreed procedure such as arbitration, and the employer gains uninterrupted production.
How well did you recall it? -
Give two factors that strengthen employees' bargaining power.
For example low unemployment and scarce skills, high union membership and unity, disruption that is costly and immediate for the employer, and public support.
How well did you recall it?
Arjun Agrawal | The Business Brief. Gathered from the platform's notes, glossary, calculation register and frameworks library. Original teaching material; not an IB publication.